ICTs and Technical Agency: A Case Study of a Rural Brazilian Community

Abstract

This paper explores the role of ICTs (Information and Communication Technologies) in rural, marginalised communities. We explore Feenberg's concept of technical agency in order to understand the ways in which technological capacity might contribute to community development. We discuss three conditions of technical agency as outlined by Feenberg; power, knowledge and appropriate occasion. We consider how this framework might enable an approach to understanding the role of ICTS in the particular social-spatial contexts in marginalised communities. In order to test Feenberg's approach we discuss a case study of a village in rural Brazil: Noiva do Cordeiro. The community is recognized regionally as a pioneer in the way that it has mobilized a range of ICTs for the benefit of the community. We will conclude by discussing how ICTs can reinforce existing or introduce technical agency in a Feenberg framework and how this might contribute to community development.

Whose Right to the Smart City?

“…In the smart city, there is little space for anyone at the margins to challenge, or even engage with the actually existing smart city. That is because the communities involved often lack the circumstances, access, and the understanding of the importance of technology for empowering themselves, either as individuals or as a collective: they lack agency (Melgaco & Willis, 2017). Rather than just perpetuating existing divides the smart city can reinforce social inequalities, since informal or marginal populations often have limited access to existing technical and urban infrastructures.…”

Responding to the urban transformation challenges in Turkey: a participatory design model for Istanbul

“…While these technology-driven solutions have been extensively used in developed countries for solving cityrelated issues or developing visions of cities, they have been used in the cities of developing countries for relatively basic urban issues. For example, ICT have been used to manage farming activities and collective knowledge sharing in Brazil, to carry out advocacy work by delivering sanitation services to informal settlements in South Africa and to share information and organise collective actions by activist organisations in Kenya and Argentina (Hirsch 2011;Mitchell and Odendaal 2015;Melgaço and Willis 2015).…”