“…If an ice core (or, at least, segregated ice) is necessary for rock glacier movement, then there are three possible mechanisms for rock glacier formation. Ice cored rock glaciers may form from burial of preexisting free-ice glaciers (e.g., Potter, 1972;Clark et al, 1994), from burial of successive snowfields by rockslides, or via ice segregation within a rock glacier (e.g, Wayne, 1981). While we agree that rock glaciers can form through burial of free-ice glaciers, the location of the majority of Lemhi Range rock glaciers along well-shaded valley walls (rather than in cirques) leads us to infer that these rock glaciers did not originate through burial of free-ice glaciers.…”