Quo vadisMFA? Integrated material flow analysis to support material efficiency

Abstract

Material efficiency (ME) strategies are pursued by governments and companies to reduce environmental emissions, improve supply chain resilience, and enhance cost competitiveness. Material flow analysis (MFA) methods are useful to quantify raw material stocks and flows and assess the potential impacts of ME strategies. Although the popularity of MFA methods is increasing, there are methodological limitations that hinder its use as a decision support tool for prospective assessments. To overcome some of these, MFA is increasingly integrated with other methods from different research fields. This paper categorizes integrated MFA methods by identifying and explaining the methods and their applications. A semi-structured literature review screened a wide range of methods integrated with MFA prospective analysis and evaluated their applications from 158 studies. This showed that integrated MFA can be used to: (1) include economic, social, and environmental layers; (2) improve the technical foundation of MFA by including entropy and exergy analyses and process engineering methods; (3) include economic mechanisms and link the economic system to the material system; and (4) improve the representation of materials in existing methods and models. Our research demonstrates that integrated MFA should be a central method in planning and designing ME strategies for companies and governments. This paper provides an important knowledge base of integrated MFA methods and creates a discussion point on MFA, where the research field is currently at or indeed where it could be heading in the future, that is, "Quo Vadis" MFA.

Extending effectiveness to efficiency: Comparing energy and environmental assessment methods for a wet cooling tower

“…While the method's general strengths and weaknesses are largely known (Angelakoglou & Gaidajis, 2015;Baars et al, 2022;Loiseau et al, 2012), we anticipate additional aspects and challenges when applying them to cooling towers, some of which appear in previous studies.…”

Thermodynamical Material Networks for Modeling, Planning, and Control of Circular Material Flows

“…One of the main methodologies to assess the circularity of materials is material flow analysis (MFA), which essentially consists of analyzing large amounts of historical data of material stocks and flows [26]- [28]. Recently, Zocco et al [11] proposed (without implementation) the development of a network of vision systems for monitoring material stocks and flows to both improve the resources management and to provide input data to MFA studies.…”

Cost versus environment? Combined life cycle, techno‐economic, and circularity assessment of silicon‐ and perovskite‐based photovoltaic systems

“…At its core, MFA refers to doing a mass balance, a fundamental concept that ensures adherence to the law of mass conservation. While suitable for single‐element bulk material flows, methodological limitations hamper its use in prospective assessments when not integrated with high‐detail approaches like process simulation (Baars et al., 2022). MFA does not suffice when the system includes complex material and minor element combinations such as those found in PV and other technologies, as it does not consider solution chemistry and cannot predict the distribution of minor elements between process outputs (Reuter et al., 2019).…”