<i>Providing the</i> CSI <i>Treatment: Criminal Justice Practitioners and the CSI Effect</i>

Wise, Jenny

doi:10.1080/10345329.2010.12035856

Cited by 10 publications

(5 citation statements)

References 8 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Ocorre que esse importante instrumento sofreu acelerada popularização entre leigos e tomou proporções erradas, sendo considerado um método de prova infalível, divulgado pelo chamado "efeito CSI" ou "CSI effect", termo que se usou para descrever o efeito que programas televisivos de investigação forense tiveram na percepção do público leigo acerca da confiabilidade do DNA (Wise, 2009).…”

Section: As Limitações Da Prova Pericial Genéticaunclassified

Anais do II Latin American Congress of Law

2022

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

APRESENTAÇÃOO II Latin American Congress of Law foi um evento criado com o objetivo de disseminar conhecimento, bons trabalhos e inovações no tema "Direito". Contou com 28 inscrições, sendo 15 ouvintes e 13 inscrições com submissões de trabalhos.Promovido pela Latin American Publicações, ocorreu de forma online, com transmissão em tempo real, com interações via chat e de forma gravada, no dia 11 de agosto de 2022. Dentro dos eixos do Congresso, 13 trabalhos científicos foram previamente lidos, analisados e aprovados pelo Comitê Científico, para posterior publicação em forma de Anais com registro CrossRef / DOI. Dos artigos aprovados, foram selecionados os três melhores trabalhos que foram certificados com o Prêmio Latin American Publicações. O evento além de proporcionar aos autores a experiência de apresentar seus trabalhos científicos, contou com dois palestrantes externos: Palestra de abertura com o Dr. Fernando Schumak Melo, intitulada "Inteligência Artificial e Poder Judiciário: onde estamos e para onde iremos" e "ESG -Outlook for Brazilian Capital Market and Companies", ministrada pelo Prof. Dr. Eduardo Agustinho.Os eixos temáticos trabalhados nesse primeiro evento foram: Direito de Família,

show abstract

Section: As Limitações Da Prova Pericial Genéticaunclassified

Anais do II Latin American Congress of Law

2022

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…More recently, studies have examined perceptions of the accuracy of forensic dramas (Maeder and Corbett, 2015), as well as how judges (Hughes and Magers, 2007), prosecutors (Stevens, 2009), criminal investigators (Huey, 2010), police officers (Maurantonio, 2012), and other members of the criminal justice system (Wise, 2010) perceive the CSI effect. Other research has examined how community members perceive the reality of the CSI effect (Hayes and Levett, 2013), and if community members (Baskin and Sommers, 2010;Brewer and Ley, 2010), potential jurors (Hayes-Smith and Levett, 2011;Shelton, Kim, and Barak, 2006), or juror-eligible college students (Maeder and Corbett, 2015;Podlas, 2005;Schweitzer and Saks, 2007) are prone to the CSI effect.…”

Section: The Csi Effect In the Literaturementioning

confidence: 99%

“…While the origin of the phrase CSI effect is unknown, Wise () reports it was first used by a journalist in 2002 to describe the negative impact that prosecutors perceived the popular fictional forensic crime drama, CSI , had on juries (Franzen, ). While there is no singular, frequently used, or precise definition of the CSI effect, it appears to encompass two main components.…”

Section: Defining the Csi Effectmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…As previously noted, several studies find that peoples’ expectations of DNA and other forensic evidence have been altered if they watch crime television programs. Additionally, some studies find that judges, prosecutors, and defense attorneys have altered their handling of evidence at trial because of their perceptions of how jurors will perceive the evidence (Hughes and Magers, ; Stevens, ; Wise, ).…”

Section: Media Crime and Cultivationmentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

The CSI Effect, DNA Discourse, and Popular Crime Dramas*

Rhineberger-Dunn

Briggs

Rader

2016

Social Science Quarterly

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Objectives Missing from the literature is an assessment of how forensic evidence, particularly DNA evidence, is portrayed across several fictional crime dramas, rather than just one drama, namely, CSI. The purpose of this article is to explore how DNA evidence is presented in four fictional crime dramas, the context in which it is discussed, and the impact DNA has on case clearance in these fictional dramas. Methods We drew a systematic sample by taking every fourth episode within each of four crime shows: CSI (Las Vegas), Law & Order: SVU, Criminal Minds, and Without a Trace. Transcripts were created for the 117 included episodes. We used both qualitative and quantitative content analyses to analyze the discourse of DNA within these crime drama episodes. Results Our results indicate that police and forensic dramas both contain frequent references to DNA, while FBI dramas rarely discuss DNA, at least in any meaningful context. Additionally, DNA is not used to solve a majority of fictional victimizations in these dramas. Conclusions These results also provide context for future research on the CSI effect, particularly in terms of measuring crime show viewership variables.

show abstract

“…52-53). Similarly, criminal justice practitioners, jury members and those involved in the criminal justice system have changed their verdict requirements (Wise, 2010). Even many defence lawyers consider DNA so infallible that they often relinquish their right to review the laboratory reports in question, accepting DNA results-or rather, their interpretation by police officials-as truth (Bliwier, 2017).…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Extended DNA analyses: surveillance technology at the intersection of racism and sexism

Bartram¹,

Plümecke²,

Nieden³

2021

Internet Policy Review

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Genetic data contains a multitude of highly personal information and is therefore deemed an especially sensitive data category by data protection laws. But technological advances and the increasing demands of security policymakers have led to the continuous expansion of governmental authority over DNA extraction, analysis and storage. The protection of women from sexual crimes is often put forward as grounds to legitimise these expansions. Sexism and racism intersect in the most recent debate on further policy change, building on existing public fears of the threat posed by unknown male migrants to white German women and presenting controversial DNA technology as a solution. Issue 4This paper is part of Feminist data protection, a special issue of Internet Policy Review

show abstract

Providing the CSI Treatment: Criminal Justice Practitioners and the CSI Effect

Cited by 10 publications

References 8 publications

Anais do II Latin American Congress of Law

Anais do II Latin American Congress of Law

The CSI Effect, DNA Discourse, and Popular Crime Dramas*

Extended DNA analyses: surveillance technology at the intersection of racism and sexism

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About