General rightsThis document is made available in accordance with publisher policies. Please cite only the published version using the reference above. Full terms of use are available: http://www.bristol.ac.uk/pure/about/ebr-terms 1 | P a g e
Back for Good: Melodrama and the Returning Soldier in Post-War Italian CinemaIn 1949, the journal Cinema published an article entitled 'Il cinema ha capito i reduci?' It reported a recent episode, in which an Italian veteran who had written to a newspaper announced that he was going to kill himself. The journalist, Lamberto Sechi, used this case as an opportunity to compare the representation of veterans in Hollywood and Italian cinema:whereas Hollywood managed to produce 'piccoli drammi intimi' that captured the alienation and out-of-placeness of the returning soldier in both its public and private aspects -in films such as The Best Years of Our Lives (Wyler, 1946) and Till the End of Time (Dmytryk, 1946) -Italian films, according to Sechi, had relied on either sentiment or on schematic ideological positions (Sechi 1949, 175).1 He cites recent films such as La vita ricomincia (Mattoli, 1946), Lattuada, 1946), and Caccia tragica (De Santis, 1947) to prove his point.However, Sechi's further claim that the reduce had become a forgotten figure onItalian screens by 1949 is not accurate. Between 1945 and 1954, Italian cinema actually produced dozens of films featuring ex-combatants. Many of these films have never been analysed by scholars, because they operate in the mode of melodrama, and thus fall outside the critical parameters that deemed (and still deem) neorealism to be the only cinematic style capable of adequately representing post-war Italian society. In this sense, Sechi's assertion that the reduce is a 'personaggio ideale di una storia facilmente commovente' is accurate (1949, 174). Despite the critical neglect of these films, however, they offer to the viewing public a figure who has 'the power to embody difficult national issues' and to 'disturb and This article will first sketch out the historical context within which the reduce is situated, highlighting the silence which surrounded the figure until recent historiography began to re-evaluate him; it will then discuss how the returning soldier, coming home to a country that fails to recognise him fully, and which is in turn unfamiliar to him, is a key 2 | P a g e figure of melodrama, a mode that itself functions in terms of (mis)recognition, and divisions of guilt and innocence, silence and expression. It will analyse how the love triangle is used in various films to represent an ideological choice, and will discuss how notions of justice and victimhood, embodied by the reduce, resonate both on a personal and public level. The nature of what the reduce has suffered, often in prison or concentration camps, cannot be described, and becomes unspeakable, with silence and circumlocution the only options, and the article will relate this private struggle for articulation with Italian repression of many aspects of its ...