This study investigated New Zealand teaching resources produced for the 100th anniversary of the First World War. The purpose was to explore how the war was viewed today by examining what was being presented to children and young people. We analysed hard copy and online resources that were specifically prepared or suggested for the anniversary. Our study revealed that the myth of the Anzac landing at Gallipoli as marking the start of Australia and New Zealand’s separation from Britain was alive and well. So, too, was the legend of the Anzac soldier as brave, stoic, resourceful and heroic. What was of particular interest, however, was that over the course of the centennial commemorations, the tone of the rhetoric moved from one of adulation to a more critical stance as a wider variety of perspectives on the war and its consequences began to appear to challenge the orthodox story of New Zealand’s role in the war. This article concludes by discussing what might be behind this upsurge in interest in the First World War before making recommendations on teaching about the war, or indeed other contested issues, in ways that acknowledge significant events yet hold unchallenged assumptions up to scrutiny.