I don't know what I know: Evidence of preserved semantic knowledge but impaired metalinguistic knowledge in adults with probable Alzheimer's disease

Abstract

Background. At what point does "not telling" become "not knowing"? Previous research shows that Alzheimer's disease (AD) affects people's ability to define words, primarily, it has been thought, because AD destroys the semantic representations of words that the patients can no longer define. We investigate an alternative hypothesis, which is the idea that AD affects metalinguistic ability, which in turn affects people's ability to produce good definitions. Aims. Does AD affect metalinguistic abilities? Are definitions poor because people lose semantic information, or because they lose the knowledge of what constitutes a good definition? Methods & Procedures. We first established what constitutes good definitions of a set of words denoting animate and inanimate concepts. We then asked elderly people with AD to define these words. As expected, their definitions were very poor. However, we then asked them forced and open-choice questions about the information that they omitted from their definitions. Outcomes & Results. We show that people with AD can access semantic information that they appear to have lost. The AD group performed significantly worse than control participants on a word definition task, but importantly, some of the information they did not provide spontaneously was offered after questioning Conclusions. We conclude that although our participants with AD have lost some semantic knowledge, on at least some occasions they do not provide information that they do still know because of a metalinguistic impairment. In particular, the participants with AD no longer understand what constitutes a good definition. We argue this metalinguistic impairment results in part from frontal atrophy. Our results have the important consequence that just because a person with AD does not offer information, even when asked, does not mean that they do not know it.

Decline and fall: A biological, developmental, and psycholinguistic account of deliberative language processes and ageing

“…Hence in addition to language-specific impairments resulting from degeneration of the language centres, we should also observe language difficulties arising from the progressive loss of deliberative processes. Harley, Jessiman, Astell and MacAndrew (2008) found that some people with probable Alzheimer's disease (AD) Deliberative processing across the lifespan frequently have access to information that they appear to have lost (see also Astell & Harley, 1998. We tested a group of elderly people with moderate AD on a word definition task.…”

Theory of Mind (ToM) and language: stimulating metalinguistic skills in people with dementia

“…Harley, Jessiman, MacAndrew and Astell (10) argue that, for this reason, metalinguistic abilities are affected in various types of dementia. Specifically, these authors found that the ability to produce adequate definitions is affected in people with Alzheimer's disease.…”

CIUs as a Measure of Communicative Performance in a Persian Speaker with Anomic Aphasia

“…'s background, increasing metalinguistic awareness and skills is suggested to be incorporated in his intervention plan. Natural metalinguistic abilities are a special type of executive process, involved in controlling and manipulating language(Harley, Jessiman, MacAndrew, & Astell, 2008). According to Hernández-Sacristán et al (2011), "Metalinguistic skills can be considered a prerequisite for the appropriate use of language in context and for functional communication".…”