Kinases are principal components of signal transduction pathways and the focus of intense basic and drug discovery research. Irreversible inhibitors that covalently modify non-catalytic cysteines in kinase active-sites have emerged as valuable probes and approved drugs. Many protein classes, however, possess functional cysteines and therefore understanding the proteome-wide selectivity of covalent kinase inhibitors is imperative. Here, we accomplish this objective using activity-based protein profiling coupled with quantitative mass spectrometry to globally map the targets, both specific and non-specific, of covalent kinase inhibitors in human cells. Many of the specific off-targets represent non-kinase proteins that, interestingly, possess conserved, active-site cysteines. We define windows of selectivity for covalent kinase inhibitors and show that, when these windows are exceeded, rampant proteome-wide reactivity and kinase target-independent cell death conjointly occur. Our findings, taken together, provide an experimental roadmap to illuminate opportunities and surmount challenges for the development of covalent kinase inhibitors.