We report the synthesis, characterization and cytotoxicity of six cyclometalated rhodium(III) complexes [CpXRh(C^N)Z]0/+, in which CpX = Cp*, Cpph, or Cpbiph, C^N = benzo[h]quinoline, and Z = chloride or pyridine. Three X‐ray crystal structures showing the expected “piano‐stool” configurations have been determined. The chlorido complexes hydrolyzed faster in aqueous solution, and reacted preferentially with 9‐ethyl guanine or glutathione compared to their pyridine analogues. The 1‐biphenyl‐2,3,4,5‐tetramethylcyclopentadienyl complex [CpbiphRh(benzo‐[h]quinoline)Cl] (3a) was the most efficient catalyst in coenzyme reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) oxidation to NAD+ and induced an elevated level of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in A549 human lung cancer cells. The pyridine complex [CpbiphRh(benzo[h]quinoline)py]+ (3b) was the most potent against A549 lung and A2780 ovarian cancer cell lines, being 5‐fold more active than cisplatin towards A549 cells, and acted as a ROS scavenger. This work highlights a ligand‐controlled strategy to modulate the reactivity and cytotoxicity of cyclometalated rhodium anticancer complexes.