“…Second, to the extent that the average water contents of core from Hole GT1A are influenced by the presence of highly altered fault zones, readers should keep in mind that the frequency and width of such zones have not yet been fully quantified for the Samail ophiolite, and are almost unknown for lower oceanic crust formed at intermediate-to fast-spreading, Pacific crust. Third, while OmanDP investigators have, like prior investigators of the Oman ophiolite (e.g., A'Shaikh et al, 2006;Kawahata et al, 2001;Pflumio, 1991), inferred that most of the low temperature, high H 2 O-content alteration minerals in the core (i.e., zeolites) formed by water-rock reactions at or near the Samail spreading center, we did not do independent work to fully rule out the alternative that some of these minerals may have formed during or post-obduction.…”