“…For example, using density functional theory (DFT) data and thermodynamic models, Hodille et al (2018) and Middleburgh et al (2014) believed the oversaturation originates from the H-induced reduction of vacancy formation energy, which promotes the vacancy amount that may accommodate excessive H atoms. Meanwhile, Gao et al (2017), Gao et al (2020) and Kato et al (2015) claimed that high concentrations of pre-existing H prevent the recombination of vacancies with self-interstitial atoms, and thus significantly reduce the displacement threshold energy and facilitate vacancy formation in W. In addition to vacancies, dislocations (Terentyev et al, 2014; and grain boundaries (GBs) have also been considered to be main contributors to H retention, although H oversaturation has been widely observed in recrystallized and/or single crystal W with very low dislocations/GBs density (Alimov et al, 2005;Zibrov et al, 2017;Zhang et al, 2021). To complicate matters further, recent experiments demonstrated that super-saturated H retention is almost independent of pre-existing impurities and defects (Jia et al, 2017), suggesting that the evolution of H itself is of high importance for such oversaturation.…”