Husserl’s Theory of Scientific Explanation: A Bolzanian Inspired Unificationist Account

Abstract

Husserl’s early picture of explanation in the sciences has never been completely provided. This lack represents an oversight, which we here redress. In contrast to currently accepted interpretations, we demonstrate that Husserl does not adhere to the much maligned deductive-nomological (DN) model of scientific explanation. Instead, via a close reading of early Husserlian texts, we reveal that he presents a unificationist account of scientific explanation. By doing so, we disclose that Husserl’s philosophy of scientific explanation is no mere anachronism. It is, instead, tenable and relevant. We discuss how Husserl and other contemporary thinkers draw theoretical inspiration from the same source—namely, Bernard Bolzano. Husserl’s theory of scientific explanation shares a common language and discusses the same themes as, for example, Phillip Kitcher and Kit Fine. To advance our novel reading, we discuss Husserl’s investigations of grounding, inter-lawful explanation, intra-mathematical explanation, and scientific unification.

Phenomenology as Proto-Computationalism: Do the Prolegomena Indicate a Computational Reading of the Logical Investigations?

“…11 Hempel had backed away from appealing to causal relations by the 1960s (due to Humean worries, according to Salmon), exposing thereby the D-N model to refutation. In a recent issue ofHusserl Studiesit's been argued that Husserl is a D-N unificationist (Williams & Byrne, 2022). This is of course right with regard to Husserl's discussion of laws and their inter-relationships; but it is also wrong, if I may say, because it leaves out causal explanation.…”

Nurcholish Madjid's Multiperspective Neuroparaemiophenomenology of Love

“…These findings would not be possible if we did not have access to higher-level schemas (Schafer, 2022). The unification theory demands us to either include these general facts as specific schemas in our explanatory store of patterns we employ to describe the world or to add some other high-level schemas that allow us to derive these conclusions (Williams & Byrne, 2022). Convergence maximization in the unification theory means that we cannot have solely reductive explanations in our explanatory store (Beach & Wise, 2022).…”