Hurricane Katrina and New Orleans: What Might a Sociological Embeddedness Perspective Offer Disaster Research and Planning?

Abstract

The Hurricane Katrina and NewOrleans situation was commonly called a "natural disaster" -an anomalous "event" that disrupted lives, spaces, and organizations. Research and planning attention then focused on particular aspects of the event and on restoring order. In contrast, sociologists and similar-thinking scholars have increasingly viewed disaster situations from multiple locations and histories, often using systems theory. Here, reanalysis of empirical material from ethnographic research in New Orleans pre-and post-Katrina suggests that a sociological embeddedness perspective illustrates the dynamic seamlessness of past, present, and future economic contexts and social actions. The perspective's constitutive concepts of weak, strong, and differentiated ties highlight the role of local knowledge, intermediary-led workforce networks, and sustained participatory planning in creating a robust economic environment. Toward this end, disaster research, planning, and theory building could incorporate network tie assessments into social vulnerability protocols, compare embeddedness with other perspectives, and learn from related international experiences. CommentsPre-peer reviewed version. Published in

Aging Disaster: Mortality, Vulnerability, and Long-Term Recovery among Katrina Survivors

“…In sum, older adults suffered disproportionately during Hurricane Katrina, partly due to the vulnerabilities of chronological age and lack of supportive evacuation, medical and other infrastructure (Iverson and Armstrong 2008). They were also the most likely to die during the storm and floods and in the year following.…”

Bonding, Bridging and Linking: How Social Capital Operated in New Orleans following Hurricane Katrina

“…In the literature, Hurricane Katrina is often categorised as a non-natural disaster-one in which social factors contributed to increased vulnerability and inhibited recovery due to lack of sociopolitical and economic resources (Cutter et al, 2003;Brinkley, 2006;Hartman and Squires, 2006;Park and Miller, 2006). The social and physical destruction of New Orleans further intensified the impact of the disaster for the most economically vulnerable (Brinkley, 2006;Hartman and Squires, 2006;Park and Miller, 2006;Iversen and Armstrong, 2008;Moyo and Moldovan, 2008).…”

Disaster research: a nursing opportunity

“…Qualitative designs describe unique contexts and circumstances and explore how culture, histology, sociology and ethnicity inform the disaster experience (Norris 2006;Norris et al 2006;Iversen and Armstrong 2008). Ethnography, phenomenology and grounded theory have been used to make people's experiences and perspectives explicit and to describe the process living through and coping in disaster (Forthergill 2004;Giarratano, Orlando and Savage 2008;Badakhsh, Harville and Banerjee 2010).…”