Hunting trophy import bans proposed by the UK may be ineffective and inequitable as conservation policies in multiple social‐ecological contexts

Abstract

The UK government is considering legislation to prohibit the importation of hunting trophies. We examine documented social, ecological, and political outcomes of two previous such bans. We find that the UK government's proposal shares the shortcomings of existing bans that have (1) failed to address, or have even amplified, key threats to hunted species, (2) imposed costs on citizens of other countries, and (3) delegitimized the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES). Trophy import bans are blunt policy instruments that can cause more problems than they solve.

Contribution of hybridization between polar bears and grizzly bears to polar bear extinction

“…Conservation practitioners also perceive the need to stop the crossing of these hybrids with exotic species (Haig & Allendorf, 2006). Sports hunters should be aware that shooting a grizzly bear without a permit in Canada can result in a large fine and even incarceration (Clark, Brehony, et al, 2022). However, what looks like a hybrid bear can turn out to be a blonde grizzly bear (Wiles, 2016).…”