Human Rights from an Islamic Perspective: A Critical Review of Arabic Peer-Reviewed Articles

Abstract

The relationship between human rights and Islam is important in countries of the Arab world where religion plays a significant role in public debates and daily life. The topic is particularly relevant at a time of sharpening conflicts and polarization, when forms of government in the region, the current world order, and the legitimacy of international organizations are increasingly contested. Much of the scholarly work published in English on this topic draws on sources available in English. This review, therefore, aims to make a contribution to the field through analysis and discussion of academic papers published in Arabic. A search was made in Google Scholar in April 2022 which yielded 12 publications published in 2020 and 2021, after inclusion and exclusion criteria had been applied. These publications were analyzed drawing on the four framing categories. A summary is also given of the definitions, sources, and premises on which the arguments of the publications draw. The reviewed papers contrast the universal and divine foundation of Islamic human rights with the limitations of modern conceptualizations based on the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR). The latter is described as emanating from Western hegemonistic aspirations and as detached from moral and spiritual values. The papers consequently argue that human rights would be guaranteed globally by generalizing a system of governance based on Shari’a law and the ideal of the Rightly Guided Caliphs. Little attention is given to human rights abuses observed in Muslim societies, diverse interpretations of Islamic source texts, or concrete measures to improve human rights protections in practice. Importantly, the arguments presented in these papers tend to reinforce a contemporary discourse that frames conflicting visions on human rights as a ‘clash of civilisations’ between ‘Islam’ and ‘the West’.

Cultural Divergence in Psychedelic Use among Medical Students: An ESPAD-Adapted Survey among Poles and Iraqis

“…It is possible that, along with religious differences, there are different mechanisms of external control (laws, rules) affecting respect for these rules (internal control). Iraqi society has been considered a society with solid traditions and control mechanisms internalized by Iraqis and strictly observed [ 32 ]. Of course, these mechanisms exist in every community and are designed to integrate society to protect against undesirable behavior, promoting security for all citizens.…”

Comprehensive approaches to child development in islamic law

“…In order to conduct a systematic study of comprehensive approaches to child development in Islamic law (Aziz et al, 2021;Chung et al, 2018), several databases and sources were used to ensure a comprehensive and full collection of relevant studies (Baas et al, 2020). A comprehensive search was conducted on academic databases including JSTOR, PubMed, Google Scholar, and the Islamic Studies Database to locate peer-reviewed journal articles, conference papers, and dissertations that examine the financial, educational, and moral dimensions of child development within the framework of Islamic law (Almahfali & Avery, 2023;D'Agostino et al, 2021;Nicholson et al, 2018). In addition, reliable online repositories and digital libraries such as Al-Islam.org and the Digital Islamic Library Project were examined to obtain classical and modern Islamic writings and scholarly interpretations (Afandi, 2020).…”

Exploiting Sociocultural Issues in Election Campaign Discourse: The Case of Nyans in Sweden

“…It is necessary, therefore, to analyze the discourse if we want to reach out and understand the reality [45] and the institution's functions in the political aspect [46,47]. CDA can also be used as a framework for the analysis of national identities [45] and human rights discourse [48]. It focuses on the form that the "language above the sentence" takes, looking at structural properties but paying little attention to the social ideas that inform the way people use and interpret language [49], with more concentration on discovering and defining the dominance of the themes [46].…”