Human nature, reason and morality

Abstract

What role should moral philosophy give to considerations about human nature and the character of human life? And what part should such considerations play in moral education? This paper explores these questions by contrasting the 'new intuitionist' position I defend in 'Practice, sensibility and moral education' (Bakhurst, 2018) with Philippa Foot's neo-Aristotelian naturalism, which holds that natural-historic description of the human life-form can furnish us with norms by reference to which failure to act morally can be understood as a kind of natural defect. Following John McDowell, I question whether a being that is rational, and therefore free, can allow such naturalhistorical description to decide norms of behaviour for it. Indeed, the new intuitionist should question whether naturalhistorical description, as Foot construes it, is even meaningful in the human case. For all that, however, I argue there is one natural-historical fact of momentous importance in understanding the human: that human beings become what they are through Bildung or education in the broadest sense. To develop this point, I turn to an unlikely ally, Immanuel Kant, who offers a robust account of Bildung designed to show how people acquire the Denkungsart (cast of mind) demanded by morality. Kant's view, I argue, presupposes knowledge of the human-as entering into both (i) the theoretical knowledge necessary to characterise the Denkungsart and the manner of its cultivation, and(ii) the practical knowledge involved in exercising it, for to be skilled at moral thinking requires understanding human life in its diversity, complexity and essential contestability. To offer

Education for metaphysical animals

“…All this reinforces a point I have made elsewhere (Bakhurst, 2021). We should not think of moral education as the learning of a particular practice, as we might think of singing, literary criticism or football.…”

Practical Exploration of Cultural Self-consciousness Enhancement of Civic Education for College Students in the Context of Deep Learning

“…Students in the values, character, ability, and other aspects of the formation of good literacy that is the subject of core literacy, it is the study of the "what to train people" problem, the depth of the learning theory to answer the "human development" of the problem, the two can not solve the problem of "how to train people." "How to cultivate people" problem [5][6]. The General High School Ideological and Political Curriculum Standards (2017 Edition Revised in 2020) clearly put forward that teachers should change their teaching methods in order to cultivate students' core literacy, which requires teachers to give full play to the auxiliary role of deep learning in the teaching of high school ideological and political courses [7].…”

The Current Occurrences of Inequality: Formation Catechist for Awareness of Significant Moral Values

“…The Catholic Church has a new awareness and special attention to the defense of human dignity, especially since the second Vatican Council in 1962Council in -1965 (Ibe & Kanu, 2022). Keep in mind that respect for human dignity as the image of God is the core and focus of our discussion (Bakhurst, 2021). The purpose of community and individual awareness is to raise our consciousness and to mindfully lower the violence that happening in our society.…”