Human Dignity as Leading Principle in Public Health Ethics: A Multi-Case Analysis of 21st Century German Health Policy Decisions

Abstract

Background: There is ample evidence that since the turn of the millennium German health policy made a considerable step towards prevention and health promotion, putting the strategies of ‘personal empowerment’ and ‘settings based approach’ high on the federal government’s agenda. This phenomenon has challenged the role of ethics in health policy. Concurrently, increasing relevance of the Concept of Human Dignity for health and human rights has been discussed. However, a direct relationship between Human Dignity and Public Health Ethics (PHE) has surprisingly not yet been established. Methods: We here conduct a systematic ethical analysis of eminent German health prevention policy case-examples between the years 2000–2016. Specifically, our analysis seeks to adapt and apply the principalism (autonomy, beneficence, justice)-based Concept of Human Dignity of Italian philosopher Corrado Viafora, contextualizing it with the emerging field of PHE. To further inform this health policy analysis, index databases (PubMed, Google Scholar) were searched to include relevant published and grey literature. Results: We observe a systematic approach of post-millennial health policy decisions on prevention and on defined health targets in Germany, exemplified by (1) the fostering of the preparedness against pandemic infectious diseases, (2) the development and implementation of the first cancer vaccination, (3) major legal provisions on non-smokers protection in the public domain, (4) acts to strengthen long term care (LTC) as well as (5) the new German E-Health legislation. The ethical analysis of these health prevention decisions exhibits their profound ongoing impact on social justice, probing their ability to meet the underlying Concept of Human Dignity in order to fulfill the requirements of the principle of non-maleficence. Conclusion: The observed health policy focus on prevention and health promotion has sparked new public debates about the formation of/compliance with emerging standards of PHE in Germany. We believe that the overall impact of this novel policy orientation will gradually show over mid- and long-term periods, both in terms of improvements in health system performance and concurrently in diagnostics, therapies and health outcome on individual patient level. The Concept of Human Dignity may soon play an even greater role in European PHE debates to come.

Cambiando paradigmas: el ejercicio físico y la resignificación jurídico-constitucional de pacientes con cáncer en Colombia

“…A la sazón, hablar de ejercicio físico, en el derecho, será el óbice estructurador para generar la polifonía interdisciplinar entre la biología, la medicina y la cultura física, o apelando al debate académico repensar la dignidad desde "healthcare professionals, lawyers, philosophers, bioethicists and politicians in general health debates" (Winter & Winter, 2018) El óbice tiene una cualidad propia, la humanidad digna. En ese entendido, el sujeto del derecho es el hombre, pero en el objeto de reflexión es el paciente con cáncer, es decir, ¿cómo increpar lingüísticamente el complemento directo de protección jurídica?…”

Psychosocial peer mediation as sustainable method for conflict prevention and management among refugee communities in Germany

“…Besides extensive political ramifications, the "European refugee crisis" is fundamentally a humanitarian crisis with a multitude of hitherto unresolved societal and public health issues. The ethical imperative to ensure human dignity and safeguard the unconditional worth of every human being constitutes an important ethical leitmotiv in German policy-making (Winter & Winter, 2018). From a humanitarian standpoint, a dignified living environment and improved access to professional health care services are pivotal, inter alia, to address the substantial burden of conflict and psychological trauma among refugee populations (Hajak et al, 2021).…”

Regional disparities in Preventive measures of COVID-19 pandemic in China. A study from international students’ prior knowledge, perception and vulnerabilities

“…Pandemics are not a phenomena; people have faced them over the centuries (Cunha 2004 , Gacel-Ávila 2005 , Winter & Winter 2018 ). For instance, the Black Death, which was the most devastating pandemic in the human history, killed almost one third of the population of the world in the fourteenth century (Cohn Jr & Weaver 2006 , Haensch et al 2010 , Wheelis 2002 ).…”