*Voiding cystouretrogram of patients with vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) demonstrated that 2 patients had grade II VUR, 2 patients had grade III VUR and 1 patient had grade IV VUR. a reduced GFR. Overall, 9 of 12 (75%) girls had some degree of renal function impairment (Table 3).We attempted to compare the length of cloacal defect (common channel ≥ 3 cm or not) with incidence of renal anomalies, presence of impaired renal function, need for bladder augmentation and urinary continence (Table 4). Renal anomalies were present in 2 of 7 patients with common channels ≥ 3 cm, compared with 1 of 5 with common channels < 3 cm (22.8% v. 20%, p = 0.73). Impaired renal function (GFR < 80mL/min) occurred in 5 of 7 children who had long common channels, compared with 3 of 5 who had short common channels (71.4% v. 60%, p = 0.24). We found a statistically significant difference between long and short common channels with regard to the patient's need for bladder augmentation. Four of 7 (57.1%) patients who had a common channel ≥ 3 cm ended up with an augmentation cystoplasty, compared with none of the patients who had a common channel < 3 cm (57.1% v. 0%, p = 0.038). Finally, we found a difference in urinary dryness when comparing long and short common channels (85.7% v. 40%, p = 0.30). Girls with longer common channels had a higher rate of urinary dryness at the expense of a higher percentage of bladder augmentation and bladder neck closure.
DiscussionUrological problems after definitive repair of cloacal malformations in children include urinary incontinence, poor renal function and recurrent urinary tract infections. Urinary continence was achieved in 67% of the patients in this study, a rate comparable with other reports (60%-83%). 4,9 Despite this apparently high rate of urinary continence in complex cases, dryness was achieved at the expense of major reconstructive surgery, such as bladder augmentation with or without bladder neck closure and clean intermittent catheterization through a Mitrofanoff conduit. In the present study, 63% of children who had dry intervals > 4 hours were on clean intermittent catheterization and 50% of them had an augmentation cystoplasty with bladder outlet closure and creation of a catheterizable conduit. Only 17% of girls who achieved dryness were voiding through the urethra. These results are far from ideal, but they are similar to those published in another series that reported that 46% of continent patients required major surgery and that no more than 22% voided spontaneously and were dry. 4 Conversely, in Hendren 10 and Pena's 11 series, 60% and 54% of children, respectively, voided spontaneously and were dry, but neither author mentioned the need for additional surgery at the level of the bladder neck.Recently, Pena reported a continence rate of 28% in girls with common channels > 3 cm and showed that these patients had a high likelihood of needing clean intermittent catheterization, compared with those with short common channels. 6 With that in mind, we attempted to compare dryness with le...