How practical is it? Machine Learning for Identifying Conceptual Interoperability Constraints in API Documents

Abstract

Building meaningful interoperation with external software units requires performing the conceptual interoperability analysis that starts with identifying the conceptual interoperability constraints of each software unit, then it compares the systems' constraints to detect their conceptual mismatch. We call the conceptual interoperability constraints (the COINs) that can be of different types including structure, dynamic, and quality. Missing such constraints may lead to unexpected mismatches, expensive resolution, and running-late projects. However, it is a challenging task for software architects and analysts to manually analyze the unstructured text in API documents to identify the COINs. Not only it is a tedious and time-consuming task, but also it needs knowledge about the constraint types. In this article, we present and evaluate our idea of utilizing machine learning techniques in automating the COIN identification, which is the first step of conceptual interoperability analysis, from human text in API documents. Our empirical research started with a multiple-case study to build the ground truth dataset, on which we contributed our machine learning COIN-Classification Model. We show the model's robustness through experiments using different machine learning text-classification algorithms. The experiments' results revealed that our model can achieve up to 87% accuracy in automatically identifying the COINs in text. Thus, we implemented a tool that embeds our model to demonstrate its practical value in industrial context. Then, we evaluated the practitioners' acceptance for the tool and found that they significantly agreed on its usefulness and ease of use.