How Health Care Professionals Use Social Media to Create Virtual Communities: An Integrative Review

Abstract

BackgroundPrevailing health care structures and cultures restrict intraprofessional communication, inhibiting knowledge dissemination and impacting the translation of research into practice. Virtual communities may facilitate professional networking and knowledge sharing in and between health care disciplines.ObjectivesThis study aimed to review the literature on the use of social media by health care professionals in developing virtual communities that facilitate professional networking, knowledge sharing, and evidence-informed practice.MethodsAn integrative literature review was conducted to identify research published between 1990 and 2015. Search strategies sourced electronic databases (PubMed, CINAHL), snowball references, and tables of contents of 3 journals. Papers that evaluated social media use by health care professionals (unless within an education framework) using any research design (except for research protocols or narrative reviews) were included. Standardized data extraction and quality assessment tools were used.ResultsOverall, 72 studies were included: 44 qualitative (including 2 ethnographies, 26 qualitative descriptive, and 1 Q-sort) and 20 mixed-methods studies, and 8 literature reviews. The most common methods of data collection were Web-based observation (n=39), surveys (n=23), interviews (n=11), focus groups (n=2), and diaries (n=1). Study quality was mixed. Social media studied included Listservs (n=22), Twitter (n=18), general social media (n=17), discussion forums (n=7), Web 2.0 (n=3), virtual community of practice (n=3), wiki (n=1), and Facebook (n=1). A range of health care professionals were sampled in the studies, including physicians (n=24), nurses (n=15), allied health professionals (n=14), followed by health care professionals in general (n=8), a multidisciplinary clinical specialty area (n=9), and midwives (n=2). Of 36 virtual communities, 31 were monodiscipline for a discrete clinical specialty. Population uptake by the target group ranged from 1.6% to 29% (n=4). Evaluation using related theories of “planned behavior” and the “technology acceptance model” (n=3) suggests that social media use is mediated by an individual’s positive attitude toward and accessibility of the media, which is reinforced by credible peers. The most common reason to establish a virtual community was to create a forum where relevant specialty knowledge could be shared and professional issues discussed (n=17). Most members demonstrated low posting behaviors but more frequent reading or accessing behaviors. The most common Web-based activity was request for and supply of specialty-specific clinical information. This knowledge sharing is facilitated by a Web-based culture of collectivism, reciprocity, and a respectful noncompetitive environment. Findings suggest that health care professionals view virtual communities as valuable knowledge portals for sourcing clinically relevant and quality information that enables them to make more informed practice decisions.ConclusionsThere is emerging evidence that hea...

The Impact of Social Media on Consumers’ Acculturation and Purchase Intentions

“…This is supported by Muhammad et al (2017) who report social factors especially social interaction to be a key motivation for social media use by consumers. Social media creates the opportunities for sharing knowledge that can be major drivers of social learning, networking and building symbiotic communal relationships on the basis of mutual trust, support and altruism (Rolls et al 2016). Other drivers of effective social media engagement, such as language, lexical expression (Hilte et al 2016), and style (Sparks et al 2013), have been found to influence the building of the communal bonds and relationships that can significantly impact customers' behavioural intention (Goh et al 2013;Laroche et al 2013).…”

“…An original contribution of the present study is the finding that the language preferences and purchase intentions that are exhibited in social networking are key forces in whether the individual chooses to consume products and services that are associated with their heritage cultures or that of the host country. Social networking also creates social relationships by providing tools with which to engage in social interactions (e.g., photo-sharing on Facebook) (Rolls et al 2016). …”

“…While the extant literature (Dessart et al 2015;Rolls et al 2016) delineates the inherent nature of social media-led communal bonding that is characterized by trust, support, and altruism, there is little empirical work on social media's influence on consumer acculturation. This paper's findings address this deficiency and augment empirical evidence and theory on social media-led acculturation.…”

Responding to Unsolicited Medical Requests from Health Care Professionals on Pharmaceutical Industry-Owned Social Media Sites: Three Pilot Studies (Preprint)

“…Consequently, they use online physician communities more so than other platforms when conducting business on social media [8,11,16]. Two leading HCP specific communities include Sermo and Doximity [11].…”

La participación de los stakeholders de las asociaciones contra el cáncer en Facebook

“…Una de las tendencias claramente señalada por estos trabajos es el uso creciente de las redes sociales en el ámbito sanitario (Green y Hope, 2010;Rolls et al, 2016). Así, por ejemplo, los datos más recientes muestran que más de un 60% de la población española recurre a internet para buscar información sobre salud y que un 20% usa las redes sociales con ese fin (ONTSI, 2016).…”