How does unemployment affect self-assessed health? A systematic review focusing on subgroup effects

Abstract

BackgroundAlmost all studies on the effect on health from unemployment have concluded that unemployment is bad for your health. However, only a few review articles have dealt with this relation in recent years, and none of them have focused on the analysis of subgroups such as age, gender, and marital status. The objective of our article is to review how unemployment relates to self-assessed health with a focus on its effect on subgroups.MethodsA search was performed in Web of Science to find articles that measured the effect on health from unemployment. The selection of articles was limited to those written in English, consisting of original data, and published in 2003 or later. Our definition of health was restricted to self-assessed health. Mortality- and morbidity-related measurements were therefore not included in our analysis. For the 41 articles included, information about health measurements, employment status definitions, other factors included in the statistical analysis, study design (including study population), and statistical method were collected with the aim of analysing the results on both the population and factor level.ResultsMost of the studies in our review showed a negative effect on health from unemployment on a population basis. Results at the factor levels were most common for gender (25 articles), age (11 articles), geographic location (8 articles), and education level (5 articles). The analysis showed that there was a health effect for gender, age, education level, household income, and geographic location. However, this effect differed between studies and no clear pattern on who benefits or suffers more among these groups could be determined. The result instead seemed to depend on the study context. The only clear patterns of association found were for socioeconomic status (manual workers suffer more), reason for unemployment (being unemployed due to health reasons is worse), and social network (a strong network is beneficial).ConclusionsUnemployment affects groups of individuals differently. We believe that a greater effort should be spent on specific groups of individuals, such as men or women, instead of the population as a whole when analysing the effect of unemployment on health.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/1471-2458-14-1310) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Do Perceptions About Local Environmental Quality Influence Self-Rated Health? Evidence from Ghana

“…Education has no effect on self-rated health. Consistent with previous findings in the literature, the results here indicate that unemployment is negatively associated with self-rated health (Giatti et al, 2011;Carlier et al, 2013;Norström et al, 2014). In other words, the unemployed were more likely to report poor health.…”

“…Also, unemployed people are found to report poor self-rated health (e.g., Giatti et al, 2011;Carlier et al, 2013;Norström et al, 2014) and this finding may hold irrespective of whether personal or contextual characteristics are controlled for (Giatti et al, 2011). The literature also shows that income is associated with self-rated health (e.g., Kennedy et al, 1998;Shibuya et al, 2002;Addai & Adjei, 2014).…”

The Bilateral Relationship between Depressive Symptoms and Employment Status

“…There is considerable evidence that men and women differ not only in their employment behavior and mental health, but also in their mental health responses to their own employment shocks as well as to those of others around them (see Novo et al 2001;Paul and Moser 2009;Marcus 2013;Bubonya et al 2014;Norström et al 2014). Given this, there is every reason to believe that the dynamic relationship between mental and economic well-being will be gendered as well.…”

“…recessions, local unemployment rates, welfare systems) (McKeeRyan et al 2005;Paul and Moser 2009;Norström et al 2014). …”

Die Gesundheit von Arbeitslosen und die Effekte auf die Arbeitsmarktintegration

“…Die Einflüsse von makroökonomischen Variablen wie Einkommensungleichheit wurden ebenfalls metaanalytisch verifiziert. Es gibt international wenige Längs-schnitterhebungen zur Gesundheit von Arbeitslosen und kaum Panelanalysen [14,20]. Das Ziel der vorliegenden Sekundäranalyse ist es daher, Erkenntnisse über die Gesundheit von Arbeitslosen in Deutschland zu gewinnen, Personengruppen mit erhöhten Krankheitsrisiken in Arbeitslosigkeit zu identifizieren, die Wechselwirkungen zwischen Arbeitsmarktintegration und Gesundheit im Zeitverlauf zu untersuchen und Implikationen für die Gesundheitsförderung abzuleiten.…”