How does the strength of ties influence relationship quality in Chinese megaprojects? The mediating role of contractual flexibility

Abstract

PurposeThis study aims to explore the influence of the strength of ties (strong ties and weak ties) on contractual flexibility (term flexibility and process flexibility) and relationship quality among stakeholders in a megaproject network.Design/methodology/approachThis study, via a questionnaire survey, collected 380 valid responses from megaproject professionals (including project managers, department managers and project engineers). The data were analyzed using least squares structural equation modeling.FindingsThe results show that both strong ties and weak ties have positive effects on relationship quality. The introduction of contractual flexibility can help improve relationship quality by combining the positive effects of the strength of ties. Interestingly, the indirect influence of strong ties on relationship quality is mainly due to term flexibility. However, the influence of process flexibility is not significant, while weak ties have an indirect influence through term flexibility and process flexibility.Research limitations/implicationsThis study, while helpful to megaproject management both in theory and practice, is nevertheless subject to several limitations. First, this study only considers the impact of the strength of ties on contractual flexibility and relationship quality; other factors, such as environmental uncertainty, are not explored. Second, the sample data are limited to just a few regions of China. Future research should cover other influencing factors, in order to make the model more substantial; data should also be collected from different cultural and industrial sources, thereby extending and further verifying the results.Originality/valueThis study makes three contributions to extant megaproject literature. First, this study provides a deep and nuanced understanding of the strength of ties. With the distinction between strong ties and weak ties clearly explained, this research furnishes a subtler understanding of relationship governance than has previously been achieved. Second, by precisely identifying the mechanism of how contract flexibility improves contract control and coordination functions, this research offers a complementary view of how contractual flexibility positively contributes to cooperation and relationship quality. Third, this study identifies which dimension of the strength of ties is more influential. This brings a new explanation for the previous controversy and offers some insight into the determinants of how to improve relationship quality in Chinese megaprojects.

The synergistic effect of the industrial international competitiveness and coopetition network position on market share: evidence from global automobile industry

“…We searched the UN Comtrade database for the world trade volume of automotive products in the home countries of the sample firms to build the trade network to measure strength, disparity and density of firms’ home country in the trade network. First, according to Freeman’s measure of node degree in undirected networks and other measure about strength of ties, the number of nearest neighbors of a node and the weights between a node and its nearest neighbors are considered in this paper (Freeman, 1978; Hu et al , 2021). The specific calculation method is as follows (“ω” represents the volume of trade): …”

Effect of network position on inter-team conflict and project success in megaprojects

“…This study uses the inputmediator-outcome model to explore the impact of network position on inter-team conflict and project success in megaprojects (Ilgen et al, 2005). This model has been widely accepted and adopted in the construction domain (Hu et al, 2021;Le et al, 2020;Wu et al, 2019;Zhang and Huo, 2015). In this research, the input variable is network position; the mediating variable is inter-team conflict; and the output variable is project success.…”

“…, 2005). This model has been widely accepted and adopted in the construction domain (Hu et al. , 2021; Le et al.…”

Information seeking and collaborative decision-making behaviour in consultancy project teams: a network theoretic viewpoint

“…The influence of strength of ties on project performance has been examined in several studies (e.g. Wu et al , 2020; Hu et al , 2021). In addition, several studies have examined the relationship between friendship ties and group decision-making in projects (e.g.…”