How Do Proxy Responses and Proxy‐Assisted Responses Differ from What Medicare Beneficiaries Might Have Reported about Their Health Care?

Abstract

Objective. Assess proxy respondent effects on health care evaluations by Medicare beneficiaries. Data Source. 110,215 respondents from the nationally representative 2001 CAHPS® Medicare Fee‐for‐Service Survey. Study Design/Data Collection/Extraction Methods. We compare the effects of both proxy respondents and proxy assistance (reading, writing, or translating) on 23 “objective” report items and four “subjective” global measures of health care experiences using propensity‐score‐weighted regression. We assess whether proxy effects differ among spouses, other relatives, or nonrelatives. Principal Findings. Proxy respondents provide less positive evaluations of beneficiary health care experiences than otherwise similar self‐reporting beneficiaries for more subjective global ratings (average effect of 0.21 standard deviations); differences are smaller for relatively objective and specific report items. Proxy assistance differences are similar, but about half as large. Reports from spouse proxy respondents are more positive than those from other proxies and are similar to what would have been reported by the beneficiaries themselves. Standard regression techniques may overestimate proxy effects in this instance. Conclusions. One should treat proxy responses to subjective ratings cautiously. Even seemingly innocuous reading, writing, and translation by proxies may influence answers. Spouses may be accurate proxies for the elderly in evaluations of health care.

Drinking Patterns of Older Adults with Chronic Medical Conditions

“…Few studies have assessed the reliability of proxy respondents for elderly individuals, but existing evidence suggests proxy responses may underestimate reported behaviors. [60][61][62][63] Persons with dementia may not recall alcohol use accurately, and 42.9 % of this cohort's respondents were proxy respondents. Additionally, the chronic conditions identified may be underestimated due to the limited one-year look-back period.…”

Is There a Relationship Between Patient Satisfaction and Favorable Surgical Outcomes?

“…Although survey scores are adjusted for mode of administration, other variables such as proxy response and assistance of a proxy in preparing the response have been found to influence satisfaction scores. 19 Twenty percent of HCAHPS surveys are completed by or with the assistance of a proxy. While life partners or spouses usually respond in a manner similar to patients, other family members and non-family members often provide a less favorable response.…”

Unveiling SEER-CAHPS®: A New Data Resource for Quality of Care Research

“…Smoking behavior and proxy assistance were both constructed from multiple survey items. 23 Age was derived using the date that the survey was received by CMS and the respondent's date of birth as it appeared on the EDB. SEER region was based upon the date of survey receipt and was taken from the year in which the survey was received for both the cancer and non-cancer groups.…”