How do physiotherapists solicit and explore patients’ concerns in back pain consultations: a conversation analytic approach

Abstract

Background: Guidelines advocate that non-specific chronic low back pain (NSCLBP) be considered within a multi-dimensional bio-psychosocial (BPS) framework. This BPS approach advocates incorporating the patient's perspective as part of the treatment process. 'Agenda setting' has been introduced as the key to understanding patients' concerns in medical encounters; however, this has received little attention in physiotherapy. This study explored how physiotherapists solicit and respond to the agenda of concerns that patients' with NSCLBP bring to initial encounters. Method: The research setting was primary care. Twenty initial physiotherapy consultations were video-recorded, transcribed and analysed using conversation analysis, a qualitative observational method. Both verbal and non-verbal features of the interaction were considered. Results: This data highlights a spectrum of communication styles ranging from more physiotherapist-focused, where the physiotherapists did not attend to patients' concerns, to a more patient-focused style, which provided greater opportunities for patients to voice their concerns. A physiotherapist-focused style tended to predominate. On occasions patients were willing to pursue their own agenda when their concern was initially overlooked. Conclusion: This study provides empirical evidence on communication patterns in physiotherapy practice. A demonstrating that a more collaborative style of communication with a shared conversational agenda provided patients with the conversational space to describe their concerns more fully.

Implementing a Dutch Physical Therapy Intervention Into a U.S. Health System: Selecting Strategies Using Implementation Mapping

“…Physical therapists acknowledge the need for a person-centered approach to care but continue to have difficulty implementing many components of person-centered care ( 22 ). The patient-physical therapist interaction is often characterized as practitioner dominant with physical therapists finding it challenging to balance their own agendas with that of the patient ( 52 , 53 ). Coach2Move is an evidence-based intervention for physical therapists in which person-centered care is foundational and improves clinical outcomes for patients.…”

Physiotherapists’ Approaches to Patients’ Concerns in Back Pain Consultations Following a Psychologically Informed Training Program

“…Using documentation during the interaction is a widely recognized barrier to effective communication (Cowell, McGregor, et al, 2019; Schoeb & Hiller, 2018). In these findings, the physiotherapists’ sensitivity to the intrusive nature of documentation was manifest in their body comportment and eye gaze away from the documentation and toward the patient (Robinson, 1998).…”

Rethinking pain education from the perspectives of people experiencing pain: a meta-ethnography to inform physiotherapy training

“…Physiotherapists were typically found to follow their own agenda, however, when a more collaborative, shared conversation style was pursued, patients were allowed to describe their concerns more fully. 59 Physiotherapists that engaged in postgraduate clinical conversation training demonstrated very positive feedback along with an increase in patient satisfaction in the service that those physiotherapists worked. 60 Research has demonstrated that people experiencing pain report that they do not always feel listened to or believed by healthcare professionals (physiotherapists included).…”