How do informal information sources influence women’s decision-making for birth? A meta-synthesis of qualitative studies

Abstract

BackgroundWomen approach birth using various methods of preparation drawing from conventional healthcare providers alongside informal information sources (IIS) outside the professional healthcare context. An investigation of the forms in which these informal information sources are accessed and negotiated by women, and how these disconnected and often conflicting elements influence women’s decision-making process for birth have yet to be evaluated. The level of antenatal preparedness women feel can have significant and long lasting implications on their birth experience and transition into motherhood and beyond. The aim of this study was to provide a deeper understanding of how informal information sources influence women’s preparation for birth.MethodsSeven electronic databases were searched with predetermined search terms. No limitations were imposed for year of publication. English language studies using qualitative methods exploring women’s experiences of informal information sources and their impact upon women’s birth preparation were included, subject to a quality appraisal framework. Searches were initiated in February 2016 and completed by March 2016. Studies were synthesised using an interpretive meta-ethnographic approach.ResultsFourteen studies were included for the final synthesis from Great Britain, Australia, Canada and the United States. Four main themes were identified: Menu Birth; Information Heaven/Hell; Spheres of Support; and Trust. It is evident that women do not enter pregnancy as empty vessels devoid of a conceptual framework, but rather have a pre-constructed embodied knowledge base upon which other information is superimposed. Allied to this, it is clear that informal information was sought to mitigate against the widespread experience of discordant information provided by maternity professionals.ConclusionWomen’s access to the deluge of informal information sources in mainstream media during pregnancy have significant impact on decision making for birth. These informal sources redefine the power dynamic between women and maternal healthcare providers, simultaneously increasing levels of anxiety and challenging women’s pre-existing ideations and aspirations of personal birth processes. A lack of awareness by some professionals of women’s information seeking behaviours generates barriers to women-centred support, leaving an experience expectation mismatch unchecked.Trial registrationCRD42016041491 17/06/16.

Women’s experiences of decision-making and informed choice about pregnancy and birth care: a systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative research

“…Previous reviews have focused on decision-making in regards to antenatal screening [17] and delayed childbearing [18], what women value during childbirth [19] and how informal information sources influence birth decisions. [20] In this review, against the changing maternity service landscape, we ask: what are women's experiences of decision-making about pregnancy and birth care, and how is informed choice being addressed in this research to date? There are many definitions of informed choice; it is generally seen as a choice that is based on availability of relevant and balanced information.…”

Exploring the use and quality of Internet discussion forums in pregnancy: A qualitative analysis

“…Time pressures and lack of a woman-centered approach are often stated as reasons why many pregnant women feel dissatisfied with the information provided by health care professionals and thus seek to fill this void by self-generated research. 1,2 Internet discussion forums provide a unique platform through which peer-to-peer information sharing gives women access to first-hand accounts of others with similar experiences. It has been reported that a majority of pregnant women consider health information on the Internet to be reliable and useful, 3 with many finding reassurance from the normalization of their experiences.…”

Effectiveness of Leadership Decision-Making in Complex Systems

“…The literature reports that many people say they rely on the internet and the huge amount of information available on social media to help them to understand and respond to complex problems. For example, the results of Sanders and Crozier [91] regarding women's decision-making when choosing birthing options in a mega study across four different countries reported that many studies show that, while women faced with this important decision used formally available and personally shared information, they also relied heavily upon information from a variety of media and from the internet in their decision-making. The internet was a powerful and immediate benefit for them in their search for information.…”