How culturally competent are hospitals in Israel?

Abstract

BackgroundCultural competence (CC) in health systems is the ability to provide care to patients with different values, beliefs and behaviors, and to match the care to their social, cultural and linguistic needs. In 2011, the Director-General of Israel’s Ministry of Health issued a cultural competence directive to health care providers that sought to minimize health inequalities caused by cultural and linguistic gaps. This study assesses the status of organizational CC in Israeli general hospitals in the wake of the 2011 directive.MethodOrganizational CC was assessed using a 75-item structured questionnaire based on the 2011 directive and on international standards. Data were gathered via interviews conducted between December 2012 and February 2014. 35 of Israel’s 36 general hospitals participated in the study, for a response rate of 97%.A composite CC score was calculated for each hospital as the average of the 75 items in the questionnaire.ResultsThe average composite score of all the hospitals was low to moderate (2.3 on a scale of 0–4), the median score was 2.4, and the range of composite scores was large, 0.7–3.2. The interquartile range was [1.94, 2.57].Hospital CC is positively associated with non-private ownership status and location in the southern or central districts. Still, these differences are not statistically significant and immutable hospital characteristics such as ownership status and location account for only 21% of the inter-hospital variation in CC. This suggests that hospital leaders have significant discretion in the priority to be given to CC.Dimensions of CC with relatively low average scores include hospital connections with the community (1.28), staff training on CC (1.35), oral translation (i.e. interpreting) during treatment (1.62), and CC adaptation of human resources recruitment and evaluation (1.64). These areas appear to be particularly in need of improvement.ConclusionThe study findings suggest that hospitals and policy-makers can take significant steps to improve CC; these include setting more concrete and measurable implementation guidelines. We conclude with suggestions for policy and practices to improve cultural competence in the health system.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s13584-018-0255-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

A multilevel investigation of cultural competence among South Korean clinical nurses

“…In this study, JCI accreditation was not a significant predictor. Similarly, in a recent study of Israeli hospitals, JCI accreditation did not have a significant effect on organisational cultural competence (56). In the hospital survey in this study, 14.3% of the hospitals received accreditation from JCI.…”

ACTION-IO as a platform to understand differences in perceptions, attitudes, and behaviors of people with obesity and physicians across countries – the Israeli experience

“…However, a high proportion of Israeli physicians considered themselves as obesity specialists (66 and 67% internationally [ 7 ]), which may have biased their responses and affected the study outcomes. It is also important to note that despite universal insurance coverage, healthcare inequities persist among the various groups of Israeli society and are largely attributed to religious, ethnical, cultural, and lingual differences [ 21 ]. Although a higher proportion of PwO in Israel responded and completed the survey when compared with the global study (63% vs 20% internationally [ 7 ]), the study design did not allow for consideration of some of these factors during sampling or weighting of PwO data.…”

Associations between ethnicity, place of residence, hearing status of family and habilitation of children with hearing impairment

“…Israeli Arabs comprise 30% of individuals with hearing loss in the educational system [ 45 ]. Although there is an exceptionally high incidence of HL among Israeli Arab children, research indicates that their parents make far less use of all types of services [ 46 ], despite a national health insurance system with universal coverage [ 47 ]. Acquisition of speech, language and hearing proficiencies requires intensive habilitation by professionals, and earlier age at intervention is associated with better oral language outcomes [ 3 ].…”