How China Divides the Left: Competing Transnational Left-Wing Alternative Media on Twitter

Abstract

Twitter has pushed public opinion on foreign policy into partisan bubbles that often value alternative media sources over traditional media or political elites. Public opinion on China is no exception. On the left, some alternative media outlets support China as a socialist ideal, while others criticize it as a key player in global capitalism and neoliberal order. This leads to an important puzzle: How and why do some transnational left media disseminate pro-China messaging while others do not? We focus on two leftist alternative media outlets: the Qiao Collective and Lausan. Both organizations claim to offer a variety of counter-hegemonic-oriented discourses. We first qualitatively analyze the differences in how these two organizations frame key topics in contemporary Chinese politics including Uyghurs in Xinjiang and the Hong Kong protests. We then use quantitative social network analysis to show how their communication efforts lead to different follower audiences. In the last step, we analyze what issues the Qiao Collective is using to achieve its inward- and outward-oriented goals. Our study shows how both outlets focus on the transnational left, but each reaches distinct audiences that do not overlap. We find that the Qiao Collective jumps on traditional left-wing issues in the US to extend its reach while regularly posting positive, often revisionist perspectives about Chinese politics. This specific element conflicts with its claim of supporting anti-imperialist and pro-democracy politics and distinguishes the Qiao Collective from other transnational left outlets.

Is #SDG13 Trending Online? Insights from Climate Change Discussions on Twitter

“…9 with the individuals from some countries showing comparatively less engagement. China a nation with highest population (more than 1.4 billion) in the world was altogether absent in the results as it has strictly banned the use of Twitter throughout the country (Singh et al, 2018b ; 2019b ; Pobiruchin et al, 2020 ; Xu et al, 2021 ; Nachman et al, 2022 ).…”

Editorial: Journalism, Activism, and Social Media: Exploring the Shifts in Journalistic Roles, Performance, and Interconnectedness

“…The thematic issue then shifts to networked communities emerging through the interaction with and the following of alternative media on Twitter. Nachman et al (2022) study how key outlets covering Chinese politics exhibit differences in their framing and how these variations contribute to the formation of almost non-overlapping network audiences. Although the two media outlets under study both connect to left-wing issues and can be each considered as a part of left counterpublics, competing interpretive communities are likely to evolve around them.…”