Households, the omitted level in contextual analysis: disentangling the relative influence of households and districts on the variation of BMI about two decades in Indonesia

Abstract

BackgroundMost of the research investigating the effect of social context on individual health outcomes has interpreted context in terms of the residential environment. In these studies, individuals are nested within their neighbourhoods or communities, disregarding the intermediate household level that lies between individuals and their residential environment. Households are an important determinant of health yet they are rarely included at the contextual level in research examining association between body mass index (BMI) and the social determinants of health. In this study, our main aim was to provide a methodological demonstration of multilevel analysis, which disentangles the simultaneous effects of households and districts as well as their associated predictors on BMI over time.MethodsUsing both two- and three-level multilevel analysis, we utilized data from all four cross-sections of the Indonesian Family life Survey (IFLS) 1993 to 2007-8.ResultsWe found that: (i) the variation in BMI attributable to districts decreased from 4.3 % in 1993 to 1.5 % in 1997-98, and remained constant until 2007–08, while there was an alarming increase in the variation of BMI attributable to households, from 10 % in 2000 to 15 % in 2007–08; (ii) ignoring the household level did not change the relative variance contribution of districts on BMI, but ignoring the district level resulted in overestimation of household effects, and (iii) households’ characteristics (socioeconomic status, size, and place of residence) did not attenuate the variation of BMI at the household-level.ConclusionsEstimating the relative importance of multiple social settings allows us to better understand and unpack the variation in clustered or hieratical data in order to make valid and robust inferences. Our findings will help direct investment of limited public health resources to the appropriate context in order to reduce health risk (variation in BMI) and promote population health.

Chronic disease concordance within Indian households: A cross-sectional study

“…Regarding phenotypic similarities between parents and their adult children, our results tended to demonstrate more statistically robust relationships compared with prior studies [ 11 , 12 ], likely due to a larger sample size and our restriction to adult children (versus adolescents and younger children). Previous analyses of chronic disease-related traits—such as continuously measured blood pressure and body mass index (BMI)—have also found that these traits are related in parent-child dyads and cluster within the household [ 8 , 9 , 13 , 40 , 41 ]. Across these previous studies and ours, generally, the correlation of obesity/BMI among family members was stronger than the correlation of hypertension/blood pressure.…”

Impact of non-communicable disease multimorbidity on health service use, catastrophic health expenditure and productivity loss in Indonesia: a population-based panel data analysis study

“…We described the patterns of multimorbidity across different population subgroups and presented the weighted percentages with 95% CI. Taking into account the hierarchical (nested) nature of the dataset (ie, observations nested within individuals, and individuals nested within households and districts), 32 a multilevel level model approach was used to examine factors associated with multimorbidity and its relation to the outcome variables. Multilevel negative binomial regression models were performed to examine the association between multimorbidity and the numbers of outpatient visits and days in the hospital.…”

Household and area-level social determinants of multimorbidity: a systematic review

“…Previous research has proposed that household factors are often overlooked in studies exploring SDoH, despite households (or families) influencing physical and mental health through various material and psychosocial factors. [73][74][75] In this review, we identified seven studies that investigated household composition and four that investigated household tenure. Composition studies presented mixed results; living alone was associated with increased multimorbidity in two studies and not associated in four.…”