Heme-copper oxidase (HCO) catalyzes the natural reduction of oxygen to water
using a heme-copper center. Despite decades of research on HCO's, the role of nonheme
metal and Nature's choice of copper over other metals like iron remains unclear. Here, we
use a biosynthetic model of HCO in myoglobin that selectively binds different nonheme
metals to demonstrate 30-fold and 11-fold enhancements in oxidase activity of Cu- and
Fe-bound HCO mimics respectively, as compared to Zn-bound mimics. Detailed
electrochemical, kinetic and vibrational spectroscopic studies, in tandem with theoretical
DFT calculations demonstrate that the nonheme metal not only donates electrons to oxygen
but also activates it for efficient O-O bond cleavage. Furthermore, the higher redox
potential of copper and the enhanced weakening of O-O bond from the higher electron
density in the d-orbital of copper are central to its higher oxidase
activity over iron. This work resolves a long-standing question in bioenergetics, and
renders a chemical-biological basis for designing future oxygen reduction catalysts.