of the core and cladding are very similar" [6]. As observed from Figure 3, this is only true for photonic-crystal fiber with small hole diameters. The validity of this approach may therefore become questionable for larger hole diameters.More accurate results may be obtained by using numerical differentiation to investigate the dispersion properties of photoniccrystal fibers. Using values of n 1 obtained by the Sellmeier equation and corresponding values of n 2eff (Fig. 3), the values of propagation constant  are calculated for different wavelengths using step-index fiber theory. The values of (⌳) against (k⌳) are modeled using a piecewise polynomial interpolation of order 3. The normalized GVD in Eq. (3) is then obtained by differentiating the interpolating polynomials. This procedure includes the effect of dispersion in silica and does not need the addition of material dispersion. Since no other approximations are used, the validity of results obtained in this way is only limited by the degree of accuracy to which the values of  have been computed. Figure 5 shows the calculated results using the two different approaches. The plots are given for the range of wavelength of interest in current optical-fiber communication systems. Moreover, outside this range of wavelength, the material (silica) dispersion predominates over waveguide dispersion.It may be observed that the normalized GVD calculated by both procedures agree for small hole diameter, but not for larger holes. This confirms the fact that the separation of normalized GVD into the two components, as in Eq. (4), is only valid for a limited range of hole diameters. The cause can be seen by examining the variation of the refractive index of silica and that of the effective refractive index with wavelength shown in Figure 3. For small hole diameter, the variation of effective refractive index with wavelength closely follows that of the refractive index of silica. However, for larger holes, the variation of effective index with wavelength diverts from that of the refractive index of silica, thus violating the principle upon which the separation is based [6].
CONCLUSIONMost of the reported research on photonic-crystal fibers uses a nominal refractive index of silica, such as the "vector methods" in [3, 7]. However, we note that in [7] material dispersion was included by using an iterative algorithm and the standard Sellmeier equation for calculating dispersion characteristics of a photoniccrystal fiber.In this paper, the separation of normalized GVD was shown to be valid only for small hole diameters, in which case the variation of the effective index closely follows that of the wavelengthdependent refractive index of silica. It was further demonstrated that, for a more accurate analysis encompassing a much wider range of hole diameters, the wavelength-dependent refractive index of silica needs to be taken into account in all calculations.