In our study, we analyzed the consequences of short selling for quantitative investment strategies held by individual investors in taxable accounts. The conventional wisdom is that the tax burden of an investment strategy increases with its turnover, because high-turnover strategies exhibit a higher propensity to realize capital gains. 1 Furthermore, short selling is often perceived to be particularly tax-inefficient because the realized capital gains on short positions are generally taxed at the higher short-term capital gains tax rate, regardless of the holding period. In this article, we show that, contrary to conventional wisdom, investment strategies that take advantage of short selling can generate relatively low tax burdens. Indeed, the addition of short positions probably enhances rather than diminishes the tax efficiency of quantitative investment strategies.One well-accepted method for managing the tax burden for individuals is to optimally time the realization of capital gains and losses, as first discussed in Constantinides (1983Constantinides ( , 1984. Investors can reduce their tax burden by accelerating capital losses and deferring capital gains. Deferring capital gains is beneficial under current law for several reasons: Long-term capital gains are taxed at a lower rate, the payment of taxes can be deferred, and the taxation of capital gains can be completely avoided when the assets pass through an estate (owing to the step-up of the cost basis at death) or are gifted to a charity. In contrast, it is advantageous to accelerate the realization of capital losses, which can be used to offset current or future capital gains in an overall portfolio. Realizing short-term losses is particularly beneficial because the short-term capital gains taxWe examine the consequences of short selling in the context of quantitative investment strategies held by individual investors in taxable accounts. Short positions not only allow investors to benefit from the anticipated underperformance of securities but also create tax benefits because they enhance opportunities to time capital gains realizations. Relaxing short-selling constraints results in tax benefits because a portfolio's long positions tend to realize net long-term capital gains taxed at relatively low rates, whereas short positions tend to realize net short-term capital losses, which can offset short-term capital gains from other strategies in the investor's portfolio. Our results show that investment strategies that take advantage of short selling can generate superior after-tax performance by significantly reducing the tax burden.
Disclosures:The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of AQR Capital Management, LLC. Further information can be found at the end of this article.We are grateful for comments and suggestions by Stephen J. Brown (executive editor), Anthony Comprelli, CFA, George Constantinides, Jacques Friedman, Luis GarciaFeijóo, CFA, CIPM, Bryan Johnson, CFA, Hoon Kim, CFA, Mark Mc...