Hidden population substructures in an apparently homogeneous population bias association studies

Abstract

Linkage-and association-based approaches have been applied to attempt to unravel the genetic predisposition for complex diseases. However, studies often report contradictory results even when similar population backgrounds are investigated. Unrecognized population substructures could possibly explain these inconsistencies. In an apparently homogeneous German sample of 612 patients with type 2 diabetic and end-stage diabetic nephropathy and 214 healthy controls, we tested for hidden population substructures and their possible effects on association. Using a genetic vector space analysis of genotypes of 20 microsatellite markers, we identified four distinct subsets of cases and controls. The significance of these substructures was demonstrated by subsequent association analyses, using three genetic markers (UCSNP-43,-19,-63; intron 3 of the calpain-10 gene). In the undivided sample, we found no association between individual SNPs or any haplogenotypes (ie the genotype combination of two multilocus haplotypes) and type 2 diabetes. In contrast, when analyzing the four groups separately, we found that there was evidence for association of the common C allele of UCSNP-63 with the trait in the largest group (n ¼ 547 cases/101 controls; P ¼ 0.002). In this subset haplotype 112 was more frequent in controls than in cases (P ¼ 0.006; haplogenotype 112/121: odds ratio (OR) ¼ 0.27, 95% confidence intervals (CI) ¼ 0.13 -0.57), indicating a protective effect against the development of type 2 diabetes. Our study demonstrates that unconsidered population substructures (ethnicity-dependent factors) can severely bias association studies.

PSORS2 Markers Are Not Associated with Psoriatic Arthritis in the Italian Population

“…These results support the evidence that PsA and Ps have disparate genetic etiology [9] , demonstrate that PSORS2 associated SNPs are not susceptibility factors in Italian Ps and PsA patients (USA and Italian population can be dissimilar in ethnicity-dependent factors [10] ) and suggest that the evidence of linkage observed for chromosome 17q25 [5] should be independent on the presence of PsA.…”

Endothelial nitric oxide synthase g894t (rs1799983) gene polymorphism in polish athletes

“…Although we have taken care to eliminate possible confounding factors, such as population stratification, which is a serious concern, especially in case-control association studies [51], this may be simply unavoidable. Berger et al showed that population substructures can be detected even in a seemingly homogenous population [52]. The effect of population admixture has been shown in the study by Saunders et al A significant difference in the GG genotype distribution between fast and slow triathletes appeared when only SouthAfrican-born athletes were considered [30].…”

Non-Replication and Inconsistency in the Genome-Wide Association Setting

“…Confounding in gene-disease associations, in particular due to population stratification, is an old concern [53][54][55][56] . Stratification may cause the appearance of spurious associations (discussed below).…”