Heteronormativity and the Justification of Gender Hierarchy: Investigating the Archival Data From 16 European Countries

Abstract

Within the framework of the System Justification Theory, this study tested on the archival data from 16 European countries the general hypothesis that homonegativity (HN), as an expression of gender binarism and heteronormativity, works as a legitimizing myth of gender hierarchy. Specifically, we hypothesized that (1) system justification (SJ) would positively relate to HN and (2) this relation would depend on the country level of gender hierarchy, (3) on the gender of respondents, and (4) on the interaction between gender hierarchy and gender. We selected the Gender Equality Index (GEI) as an indicator of the gender hierarchy of the country system and the items from the European Social Survey-Round 9 (ESS-9) as the indicators of the gender of respondents and the levels of SJ and HN. The Hierarchical Linear Modeling (HLM) partially confirmed the hypotheses, suggesting HN to work as a blatant prejudice and being more viable as a legitimizing myth in females from countries with higher gender hierarchy and in males from more gender-equal countries. In both cases, HN serves as a myth to justify the ontological premise of participants that the world is fair and to counteract the cognitive dissonance generated by the perception of a gender-unequal system (in the case of a woman) or by the perception of a gender-equal system that can threaten gender privileges (in the case of a man).

Everyday prejudices: an intersectional exploration of the experiences of lesbian and gay entrepreneurs

“…Furthermore, there is evidence to suggest that LGBTQþ people view gender as a heteronormative binary (Rocha Baptista and de Loureiro Himmel, 2016;Ferrari and Mancini, 2020;Kowalsky and Scheitle, 2020) with high levels of sexism, particularly where conservative ideologies are present (Tatum and Ross, 2020;L opez-S aez and Platero, 2022). This outgroup favouritism can be understood as an alliance with the group-based stable social hierarchies (Ferrari et al, 2021) and in the case of the white, gay male entrepreneurthe male-dominated gender system.…”

Hetero‐ and cisnormativity—UK pharmacy education as a queer opponent

“…This heterosexual male hierarchy binarises gender and sexual orientation and gives rise to homonegativity or the negative attitude towards sexual divergence. 3 Genderfication, the binarised view of gender, involves the standardisation of gender within the heteronormative construct of male/female, boy/girl.…”

“…The concept of heteronormativity is grounded in post‐structuralist feminist theory where heterosexual male dominance is critiqued as both a societal norm and social conditioning. This heterosexual male hierarchy binarises gender and sexual orientation and gives rise to homonegativity or the negative attitude towards sexual divergence 3 . Genderfication, the binarised view of gender, involves the standardisation of gender within the heteronormative construct of male/female, boy/girl.…”

Gender, Shame, and Social Support in LGBTQI+ Exposed to Discrimination: A Model for Understanding the Impact on Mental Health

“…Heterosexism has, therefore, historically caused and reproduced a wide range of stereotypes, prescribing the acceptable identities and expected behaviors and marginalizing any other type of nonconforming expressions and existences (Marchia and Sommer 2019). Most who do not conform to a binary gender and hetero and mono-normative sexualities and intimacies are exposed to discrimination and other forms of unequal treatment (Ferrari et al 2021).…”