Heterogeneity in Domestic Water Demand: An Application of Multilevel Analysis to the City of Valencia (Spain)

Abstract

This paper deals with the question of unobservable heterogeneity and problems of scale in urban water demand. For this purpose, the determinants of domestic water consumption and the elasticities were estimated using a hierarchical model. For our empirical analysis, a household level data panel from Valencia (Spain) between 2009 and 2011 was available. Households were assigned to the city neighbourhoods to which they belong, which allowed us to incorporate the intra-urban scale into the analysis. In the estimate, the average price paid by each household in each bimonthly period was used due to the current tariff structure in Valencia. Regarding our results, there were differences in the consumption between the different neighbourhoods that were not independent of the average price paid by households. We found that 27% of the variability in consumption was explained by differences in household behaviour. In addition, an average price-elasticity in Valencia for all periods of −1.868 was obtained as well as a range of elasticities for the different neighbourhoods between (−1.53 and −1.21). From the results obtained, it is possible to extract relevant information for local water managers in order to apply economic instruments, prices and taxes to urban water demand.

Are Economic Tools Useful to Manage Residential Water Demand? A Review of Old Issues and Emerging Topics

“…Generally, household size has a positive effect on water consumption [21,22,31,33,41,43]. Previous research has found that water consumption increases less than proportionally to the increase in household size, likely due to economies of scale [1,45,52]. As pointed out by Marzano et al [44], per-household consumption increases with household size, but percapita consumption decreases [53,54].…”