Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) may recur after liver transplantation (LT), mainly in patients with multinodular and large tumors. However, factors predictive of outcome after LT in patients with small tumors remain ill defined. We investigated which factors were related to mortality or tumor recurrence among 47 liver transplant recipients with liver cirrhosis and HCC and compared them with 107 patients with liver cirrhosis without tumor who underwent LT in the same period. Patients with HCC were older (P < .001), more frequently had cirrhosis of a viral origin (P < .001), and had lower Child-Pugh scores (P < T he role of liver transplantation (LT) in the treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) has evolved. In the early ages, LT was indicated in all cases of unresectable HCC without known extrahepatic spread. 1,2 Long-term survival was poor among patients with advanced disease because of a high incidence of tumor recurrence. 3 In the 1990s, several series showed that early HCC seldom recurred after LT and survival was similar in patients with cirrhosis with or without HCC. 2,4-6 Some prefer LT over resection in these patients. 2,[6][7][8] Several studies investigated which factors predispose to HCC recurrence after LT. Several investigators studied which factors are related to post-LT outcome. 2,5,[8][9][10][11] Llovet et al 5 did not find any factor predictive of post-LT outcome. In other series, poor differentiation, vascular invasion, greater number of tumor nodules, and greater tumor size were related to lower survival or disease-free survival rates, 2,8,9,11 but most series were based on unselected groups of patients and included a considerable proportion of patients with large nodules..The present study investigates factors associated with mortality and tumor recurrence among 47 patients with HCC who underwent LT according to well-defined selection criteria in a single center.
Patients and MethodsBetween 1991 and June 2000 in our center, 160 adult patients with liver cirrhosis underwent a first LT. Forty-seven of these patients also had HCC diagnosed before LT, 6 patients had incidental HCC, and 107 patients had liver cirrhosis without HCC. Patients with incidental HCC were excluded from this retrospective study.Patients with HCC were selected for LT if they had a single nodule not exceeding 60 mm in diameter or 2 or 3 tumors, none exceeding 50 mm in diameter, assessed by computed tomographic (CT) scan. Patients in whom vascular invasion or extrahepatic spread was evident preoperatively were excluded. LT was considered the treatment of choice for all patients with HCC if they fulfilled these criteria and did not have a contraindication for LT. Patients with HCC did not have a priority for LT compared to other patients with cirrhosis. During this period, only 2 patients were excluded from the LT waiting list 6 and 7 months after their listing because of progressing HCC.As well as ultrasonography and CT scan, hepatic angiography was generally performed before LT. When HCC had been detected or suspected an...