Henry's voices: the representation of auditory verbal hallucinations in an autobiographical narrative

Abstract

The book Henry's Demons (2011) recounts the events surrounding Henry Cockburn's diagnosis of schizophrenia from the alternating perspectives of Henry himself and his father Patrick. In this paper, we present a detailed linguistic analysis of Henry's first-person accounts of experiences that could be described as auditory verbal hallucinations. We first provide a typology of Henry's voices, taking into account who or what is presented as speaking, what kinds of utterances they produce and any salient stylistic features of these utterances. We then discuss the linguistically distinctive ways in which Henry represents these voices in his narrative. We focus on the use of Direct Speech as opposed to other forms of speech presentation, the use of the sensory verbs hear and feel and the use of 'non-factive' expressions such as I thought and as if. We show how different linguistic representations may suggest phenomenological differences between the experience of hallucinatory voices and the perception of voices that other people can also hear. We, therefore, propose that linguistic analysis is ideally placed to provide in-depth accounts of the phenomenology of voice hearing and point out the implications of this approach for clinical practice and mental healthcare.

Person-ness of voices in lived experience accounts of psychosis: combining literary linguistics and clinical psychology

“…More generally, Carl only uses 'say' as a speech-activity verb in relation to his voices, whereas Orla uses eight such verbs ('mumble', 'repeat', 'say', 'scream', 'speak', 'talk', 'tell', 'whisper'). While some voice-hearers use direct speech extensively to represent their voices' utterances, 32,33 Carl and Orla mainly use non-direct categories, and particularly Indirect Speech (e.g. Orla: 'she could tell us just to go hurt someone in public') and Narrator's Representations of Speech Acts (e.g.…”

The space between words: on the description of Parkinson’s disease in Jonathan Franzen’s 'The Corrections'

“…Indeed there has been an increased emphasis on the humanities and arts in medical curricula [5][6][7]. Along with patient/service user testimonies or stories, many researchers argue that fiction/literary-focused medical humanities can be an important way of understanding lived experience [8][9][10].…”

Illusory social agents within and beyond voices: a computational linguistics analysis of the experience of psychosis

“…Initial studies have applied this approach to understanding the experience of hallucinated voices in psychosis. Demjén and Semino (2015) initially applied this to the experience of voices as described in a published autobiographical account and later to interviews with 40 voices hearers in an early intervention programme for psychosis (Collins et al, 2020) – reporting how linguistic features represented important features of identity and social interaction with voices that related to voice-related distress. Indeed the social features of voices have been previously identified as being important in driving the distress and disability associated with voice hearing in psychosis (Mawson et al, 2010).…”