Hedging and Vertical Integration in Electricity Markets

Abstract

This paper analyzes the interactions between competitive (wholesale) spot, retail, and forward markets and vertical integration in electricity markets. We develop an equilibrium model with producers, retailers, and traders to study and quantify the impact of forward markets and vertical integration on prices, risk premia, and retail market shares. We point out that forward hedging and vertical integration are two separate mechanisms for demand and spot price risk diversification that both reduce the retail price and increase retail market shares. We show that they differ in their impact on prices and firms' utility because of the asymmetry between production and retail segments. Vertical integration restores the symmetry between producers' and retailers' exposure to demand risk, whereas linear forward contracts do not. Vertical integration is superior to forward hedging when retailers are highly risk averse. We illustrate our analysis with data from the French electricity market. This paper was accepted by Wei Xiong, finance.corporate finance, industries, electric-electronic, financial institutions, markets, asset pricing

Reinsurance or securitization: The case of natural catastrophe risk

“…Our result can be interpreted as stating that catastrophe risk information produced in financial markets under present conditions would be primarily in the nature of foreknowledge. Our focus on information production costs complements Aïd et al (2011) focus on risk aversion as limiting the use of financial markets for the purpose of transferring risk. The authors consider the electricity market; electricity's non-storable nature introduces an asymmetry between the production and retail sectors' exposures to demand risk.…”

“…The authors consider the electricity market; electricity's non-storable nature introduces an asymmetry between the production and retail sectors' exposures to demand risk. They show that vertical integration restores symmetry between producers and retailers' exposure, whereas linear forward contracts do not; they conclude that ''[v]ertical integration is superior to forward hedging when retailers are highly risk averse'' (Aïd et al, 2011(Aïd et al, , p. 1438.…”

A Survey of Commodity Markets and Structural Models for Electricity Prices

“…More sophisticated methods use stochastic control techniques to take full advantage of the optionality of the plant. See for example [30,3]. Moreover, some of these methods have been extended to value gas storage and we refer the interested reader to [28,27,50,77].…”

Financing Power: Impacts of Energy Policies in Changing Regulatory Environments

“…This in turn implies that the project needs to obtain additional support to break even and hence directly translates into additional deployment costs. While we focus the subsequent discussion on investments through project finance, the analysis and results holds similarly for vertically-integrated companies, as Finon (2008) describes how long-term contracts between generators and retailers and vertical integration are substitutes to establish the required long-term cash flow security, and Aïd et al (2011) argue that which construct will prevail depends on the degree of uncertainty.…”