Healthcare personnel’s experiences of situations in municipal elderly care that generate troubled conscience

Abstract

Healthcare personnel may perceive troubled conscience when feeling inadequate and powerless. It is important to further explore healthcare personnel's descriptions of situations in daily work, which generate troubled conscience to increase the awareness of such situations. This study aimed to describe health care personnel's experiences of situations in municipal elderly care that generate troubled conscience. In this qualitative study, interviews were conducted with Registered and Enrolled nurses and nursing assistants (n = 20) working in municipal elderly care. The interviews were tape-recorded, transcribed verbatim and analysed with content analysis. Situations that generated troubled conscience was (i) Being caught between different demands, comprising being forced to prioritize between different residents' needs, being torn between residents'-/relatives'-/and co-workers' needs and expectations' and between work and private life, (ii) Being torn away from residents to other 'must do's', comprising stealing time from residents' to do housekeeping chore' and to 'obey' rules and recommendations, (iii) Feeling unable to relieve suffering, comprising falling short when striving to help, lacking knowledge, advice and support and time to ease residents' suffering and finally, (iv) Being part of providing care that is or feels wrong, comprising providing poor care and/or witnessing co-workers providing poor care, and being forced to give care that feels wrong. These findings identify important factors that generate stress of conscience (stress caused by troubled conscience), including difficulties with balancing priorities and following rules and recommendations that seem contrary to best care, and the need for interdisciplinary teamwork. Findings point to that sharing what conscience tells in the work team opens up possibilities for healthcare personnel to constructively deal with troubled conscience. Intervention studies are needed to explore whether such measures contribute to relieve the burden of troubled conscience and increase possibilities to provide high quality care.

In Hospital We Trust: Experiences of older peoples' decision to seek hospital care

“…This is especially true during nights with fewer personnel. 33 It is important to provide information to patients regarding when and how to reach home health care staff, as well as what type of services home health care can provide.…”

Encountering existential loneliness among older people: perspectives of health care professionals

“…A study by Norell Pejner, Ziegert, and Kihlgren (2012) showed that although nurses considered giving emotional support to older people important, and knowing when it is needed as part of their professional skill set, work conditions did not always allow time for that. Ericson-Lidman, Norberg, Persson, and Strandberg (2013) showed that health care personnel were troubled by conscience when caught between various demands, rules, and recommendations that did not benefit the older people; they felt unable to relieve suffering and provide proper care to their patients. This indicates that being unable to work and act according to one’s values could create a feeling of guilt among professionals and promote neither good encounters nor good relations.…”

Quality care provision for older people: an interview study with patients and primary healthcare professionals

“…20 Another study confirmed the finding that nurses often feel caught in a difficult position between patients and doctors. 17 In addition, a review on quality improvement in care homes, which focused on the management of specific physical health needs, argued that structured interventions in shared planning are necessary. 21 The current study reveals a picture of varying quality in care.…”