Health services in Trinidad: throughput, throughput challenges, and the impact of a throughput intervention on overcrowding in a public health institution

Abstract

BackgroundThroughput might be partially responsible for sub-optimum organisational and medical outcomes. The present study examined throughput and the challenges to ensuring optimum throughput in hospitals, and determined the effectiveness of a throughput intervention in reducing overcrowding in a public healthcare institution in Trinidad and Tobago.MethodsFirst, a literature review of throughput and its processes in relation to improving hospital care was conducted. Second, the challenges to throughput in healthcare were reviewed. Data were also collected from print media, hospital records, and the central statistical office in Trinidad and Tobago to discuss throughput and describe the throughput status in hospitals. Finally, the effect of a throughput intervention on overcrowding was determined. The intervention was implemented over six months, from October 2010 to March 2011, and comprised three stages of a five-stage throughput process: transferring patients to a specific medical ward, bedside electrocardiograms (ECG), and promptly obtaining patient investigative reports and patient files.ResultsProblems with the throughput process led to prolonged delays or failures in obtaining lab reports, radiology services, ECGs, and pharmaceutical supplies, as well as inadequate social work services and other specialised services. During the throughput intervention, there was a reduction in overcrowding/overflow to 5–10 patients per day with a daily admission rate of 58. However, at post-intervention, there was increased overcrowding/overflow to 20–30 per day but fewer admissions (52 per day) i.e. similar to pre-intervention period. Additionally, there was an increase in bed complement in the department of medicine from 209 (2011) to 227 (2012). Overcrowding continued into 2016 and beyond: medical admissions in 2016 were 46.4 per day and the medical bed capacity was 327 (indicating a 44% increase in capacity from 2012).ConclusionHospital throughput processes are currently suboptimum. Improving specific throughput processes or targeting the greatest primary constraints might help decrease overcrowding.

Access to WHO Essential Medicines for Childhood Cancer Care in Trinidad and Tobago: A Health System Analysis of Barriers and Enablers

“…Our findings are relevant to broader health systems strengthening in T&T, because many proposed enablers of drug access would enhance overall health system performance. For instance, recent reports have suggested that institutional process inefficiencies, such as delays in hospital diagnostics resulting from inadequate staffing, create significant barriers to accessing health services in T&T. 24,25 Themes for policy reform from our study, such as increased standardization of intra-and interinstitutional processes in the pharmaceutical sector, may therefore be relevant in addressing other health system inequities as well, including access to diagnostic services and wait times for specialist care. 25 An underlying objective of our study was to develop health system capacity in T&T by equipping local stakeholders with policy-relevant data.…”

Safety and Cost-Savings of Same-Day Discharge Trans-Radial Percutaneous Coronary Intervention in Trinidad and Tobago

“…With the high economic burden of non-communicable diseases (NCDs), appropriate funding of the health sector in this small island developing state is a major step towards tending to the needs of the population. Public health services are currently free for patients, however, there has been a multitude of reports highlighting the poor performance of the public health sector in large part due to overcrowding [8,9]. This has been attributed to poor hospital throughput -defined as the number of patients served in a unit of time [8].…”

“…Public health services are currently free for patients, however, there has been a multitude of reports highlighting the poor performance of the public health sector in large part due to overcrowding [8,9]. This has been attributed to poor hospital throughput -defined as the number of patients served in a unit of time [8]. With the increased demand for hospital beds and high volume of angiograms and PCIs, hospitals remain under constant pressure to provide patients with appropriate post-procedural care and safe discharge.…”

An Analysis of the Problems Users Experience in Public Health Care Facilities in Trinidad and Tobago

“…Bahall [9] suggests that over the last few decades Trinidad and Tobago's health services have been plagued by inefficiencies partly emanating from poor throughput processes. He argues that reports from numerous commissions, hospital administrators, and healthcare providers have alluded to inefficiencies and poor throughput processes.…”

“…He argues that reports from numerous commissions, hospital administrators, and healthcare providers have alluded to inefficiencies and poor throughput processes. Furthermore, Bahall [9] states that in 1970, the editorial of a daily newspaper reported that a full-scale enquiry into the concern was needed, since the crisis in the nation's health services seems to be getting dangerously close to the point of total collapse, (Bahall [9]).…”