Health decentralization at a dead-end: towards new recovery plans for Italian hospitals

Abstract

a b s t r a c tThe recent introduction by the central government of recovery plans (RPs) for Italian hospitals provides useful insights into the recentralization tendencies that are being experienced within the country's decentralized, regional health system. The measure also contributes evidence to the debate on whether there is a long-term structural shift in national health strategy towards more centralized stewardship. The hospital RPs aim to improve the clinical, financial and managerial performance of public-hospitals, teaching-hospitals and research-hospitals through monitoring trends in individual hospitals' expenditure and tackling improvements in clinical care. As such they represent the central governments recognition of the weaknesses of the decentralization process in the health sector. The opponents of the reform argue that financial stability will be restored mainly through across-the-board reductions in hospital expenditure, personnel layoffs and closing of wards, with considerable negative effects on the most vulnerable groups of patients. While hospital RPs are comprehensive and complex, unresolved issues remain as to whether hospitals have the necessary managerial skills for the development of effective and achievable plans. Without also devising an overall plan to tackle the long-standing managerial weaknesses of public hospitals, the objectives of the hospital RPs will be undermined and the decentralization process in the health system will gradually reach a dead-end.

The Dangers of Fiscal Decentralization and Public Service Delivery: a Review of Arguments

“…The latter view is also supported by the current discussion on recentralization in various developed countries as recorded by Saltman (2008). One frequently cited example of recentralization is Italy, where the central government introduced hospital recovery plans including, for example, closing down small hospitals in order to better benefit from economies of scale and to make the allocation of human resources more efficient (Mauro et al 2017). The case of Spain exemplifies the difference between the decentralization of spending and revenue competences.…”

Covid-19 pandemic and pediatric healthcare policy in Italy: time for a change

“…Whether this was effective and convenient is today deeply challenged, or even rejected by those who strongly recommend its return to a unique NHS. 7 Devolution has been justified by the aim at economies and better administration by managers located closer to the activities. However, is it only a matter of money and resources invested?…”

Insights on the effectiveness of reward schemes from 10‐year longitudinal case studies in 2 Italian regions.

“…Because regions are autonomous to choose their organisational model, they adopted different governance models and management tools . However, more and more the central government has been controlling performance over regions, claiming, since 2010, an increasingly central role when regions were not able to achieve the minimum level of performance set through the ELC …”