Health Care Professionals’ Experiences of Patient-Professional Communication Over Patient Portals: Systematic Review of Qualitative Studies

Abstract

Background The popularity of web-based patient-professional communication over patient portals is constantly increasing. Good patient-professional communication is a prerequisite for high-quality care and patient centeredness. Understanding health care professionals’ experiences of web-based patient-professional communication is important as they play a key role in engaging patients to use portals. More information is needed on how patient-professional communication could be supported by patient portals in health care. Objective This systematic review of qualitative studies aims to identify how health care professionals experience web-based patient-professional communication over the patient portals. Methods Abstract and full-text reviews were conducted by 2 reviewers independently. A total of 4 databases were used for the study: CINAHL (EBSCO), ProQuest (ABI/INFORM), Scopus, and PubMed. The inclusion criteria for the reviewed studies were as follows: the examination of health care professionals’ experiences, reciprocal communication between patients and health care professionals, peer-reviewed scientific articles, and studies published between 2010 and 2019. The Joanna Briggs Institute’s quality assessment criteria were used in the review process. A total of 13 included studies were analyzed using a thematic synthesis, which was conducted by 3 reviewers. Results A total of 6 analytical themes concerning health care professionals’ experiences of web-based patient-professional communication were identified. The themes were related to health care professionals’ work, change in communication over patient portals, patients’ use of patient portals, the suitability of patient portals for communication, the convenience of patient portals for communication, and change in roles. Conclusions Health care professionals’ experiences contain both positive and negative insights into web-based patient-professional communication over patient portals. Most commonly, the positive experiences seem to be related to the patients and patient outcomes, such as having better patient engagement. Health care professionals also have negative experiences, for example, web-based patient-professional communication sometimes has deficiencies and has a negative impact on their workload. These negative experiences may be explained by the poor functionality of the patient portals and insufficient training and resources. To reduce health care professionals’ negative experiences of web-based patient-professional communication, their experiences should be taken into account by policy makers, health care organizations, and information technology enterprises when developing patient portals. In addition, more training regarding web-based patient-professional communication and patient portals should be provided to health care professionals.

Healthcare professionals' perceptions of digital health competence: A qualitative descriptive study

“…HCPs seemed to possess complex perceptions of how digital health affects patient care and, subsequently, the competence requirements of HCPs. Ambivalent perceptions of the effects of digital health have already been previously reported (Odendaal et al 2020 , Laukka et al, 2020 ). The interviewees had a positive outlook on digital health services, either as a whole or specific aspects of digital health, but also recognized the challenges associated with digitalization.…”

“…HCPs' competence in digitalization has been previously described as consisting of sufficient skills in using digital technology to provide high‐quality ethical patient care, social and communication skills to use digital technology in health prevention, diagnoses and treatment, willingness and motivation to apply digital technology in a professional context, and collegial and organizational support to enhance positive experiences in digitalization (Konttila et al, 2018 ). Previous reports of HCPs' experiences of using digital health services have highlighted both negative and positive aspects, with the negative experiences most commonly related to HCPs' perceptions of their lack of competence in communication with patients through patient portals (Laukka et al, 2020 ), treatment and screening algorithms threatening their clinical competency (Odendaal et al 2020 ) and doubts over whether digital health improves patient care (Ross et al, 2016 ). Barriers such as the poor design of services and careless implementation process as well as lack of access to devices have been identified as inhibiting the use of digital technology in health care and HCPs possess concerns over technology taking time from direct patient care and causing additional stress due to malfunctioning systems (Brown et al, 2020 ).…”

Mental Health Care Professionals’ Appraisal of Patients’ Use of Web-Based Access to Their Electronic Health Record: Qualitative Study

“…For example, our participants were afraid that patients might share their medical records with an unauthorized person or authority, which could make patients more vulnerable to people or institutions with conflicting interests. A recent review similarly raised this concern regarding patients autonomously handling medical information [ 30 ]. Another study found that a major barrier to redefining work practices of health care professionals through the use of patient portals in hospital care concerned privacy and security [ 31 ].…”

Future of Surgery: Technology Enhanced Surgical Training: Report of the FOS:TEST Commission

“…Using digital solutions rather than face-to-face care interactions to deliver personalised care will require a new skillset for both trainees and trainers. 30 The challenges of communicating remotely by telephone or video need to be considered since establishing rapport, obtaining accurate information, conveying attention and empathy to the patient, and accurate understanding may be more challenging. These challenges are particularly relevant given that groups who may most require personalised care tend to also require support in accessing and using digital solutions.…”