Health care inequality under different medical insurance schemes in a socioeconomically underdeveloped region of China: a propensity score matching analysis

Abstract

BackgroundSince economic inequality is often accompanied by health inequalities, health care inequalities are increasingly becoming a hot issue on a global scale. As a developing country, China is still facing the same problems as other countries in the world. Especially in underdeveloped regions, owing to the relatively backward economy, health care inequality may be more serious. The objective of this study was to explore health care inequality in a socioeconomically underdeveloped city, thus providing a certain theoretical basis for further development and reform of the medical insurance schemes.MethodsWe mainly extracted relevant insurance information of 628,952 insured enrollees, as well as consumption of outpatient visit and hospitalization. The propensity score matching had been used to estimate different urban medical insurance schemes effect on healthcare utilization, the choice of hospital types and healthcare cost.ResultsInsured enrollees spent most hospitalization expenses in tertiary-level hospitals, which had lowest hospitalization compensation ratios. Healthcare utilization and cost vary significantly by different insurance schemes. Urban employees had significantly higher outpatient visit rates in all hospital types than urban residents. Urban employees preferred to receive hospitalization treatment in tertiary-level hospitals, while those who receive hospitalization treatment in first-level hospitals are more likely to be enrolled in Urban Residents Basic Medical Insurance. Hospitalization expenses and hospitalization compensation ratios of urban employees were also significantly higher than urban residents in all hospital types.ConclusionsHealth care inequality is mainly reflected in the imbalance between hospitalization expenses and hospitalization compensation ratios, as well as inequalities under different medical insurance schemes in healthcare utilization, the choice of hospital types and healthcare cost in socioeconomically underdeveloped regions of China. We should conduct a targeted medical insurance reform for the socioeconomically underdeveloped regions, rather than applying templates of ordinary regions. Further efforts are needed in the future to provide equal health care for every patient.

What Are the Determinants of the Decision to Purchase Private Health Insurance in China?

“…Moreover, PHI has the potential to exacerbate health inequalities in China. Health insurance schemes were examined to have an impact on healthcare utilization and costs [39], and different health insurance schemes may be associated with healthcare utilization inequality [40]. There are demands in China to distribute access to healthcare services more equitably, in line with the population's needs rather than their ability to pay [41].…”

“…Our findings demonstrate the importance of household financial status, geographical factors, and SBMI type as associated with the decision to purchase PHI. Different SBMI schemes caused variation in inequalities in accessing healthcare [40], and the acquisition of PHI might further exacerbate this inequality. This warrants study in future work.…”

The outcome and burden of Chinese patients with neurodegenerative diseases: A 10‐year clinical feature study

“…Our result showed the admission source was mainly outpatient, but most admission source of hospitalisation is in Emergency Rooms in many Western countries 24 . Which is mainly related to different medical insurance policies and national conditions 19,25,26 . Our results showed the NDDs patients accompanied by various comorbidities, most common comorbidities were hypertension, diabetes, and cerebrovascular diseases.…”

Time Trends and Regional Disparities of Maternal Mortality Ratio: Evidences From China, 1990-2018.

“…However, the aged, kids, students, and urban non-employed rural residents were not included in the Urban Employees Basic Medical Insurance system. Therefore, in order to solve the problem, the Urban Residents Basic Medical Insurance scheme was established since 2007, and the scheme improved the health care of some groups and the inequality of health care [22] . The New Cooperative Medical Scheme offered subsidies for rural residents on antenatal and postnatal services and encouraged hospital delivery, either as a prepayment or a retrospective reimbursement [23] .…”