Health and Economic Impact of Health Warnings and Plain Tobacco Packaging in Seven Latin American Countries: Results of a Simulation Model

Abstract

Introduction The burden of disease attributable to tobacco use in Latin America is very high. Our objective was to evaluate the 10-year potential impact of current legislation related to cigarette packaging and warnings and expected effects of moving to a higher level of strategies implementing cigarette plain packaging on health and cost outcomes in Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Mexico, and Peru, using a microsimulation model. Aims and Methods We used a probabilistic state-transition microsimulation model, considering natural history, costs, and quality of life losses associated with main tobacco-related diseases. We followed up individuals in hypothetical cohorts and calculated health outcomes annually to obtain aggregated long-term population health outcomes and costs. We performed a literature review to estimate effects and analyzed studies and information from ministries, relevant organizations, and national surveys. We calibrated the model comparing the predicted disease-specific mortality rates with local statistics. Results Current graphic warnings already in place in each country could avert, during 10 years, 69 369 deaths and 638 295 disease events, adding 1.2 million years of healthy life and saving USD 5.3 billion in the seven countries. If these countries implemented plain packaging strategies, additional 155 857 premature deaths and 4 133 858 events could be averted, adding 4.1 million healthy years of life and saving USD 13.6 billion in direct health care expenses of diseases attributable to smoking. Conclusions Latin American countries should not delay the implementation of this strategy that will alleviate part of the enormous health and financial burden that tobacco poses on their economies and health care systems. Implications Tobacco smoking is the single most preventable and premature mortality cause in the world. The Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, supported by the World Health Organization, introduced a package of evidence-based measures for tobacco control. This study adds evidence on the potential health effects and savings of implementing cigarette plain packaging in countries representing almost 80% of the Latin American population; findings are valuable resources for policy makers in the region.

Estimated Prevalence of Smoking and Smoking-Attributable Mortality Associated With Graphic Health Warnings on Cigarette Packages in the US From 2022 to 2100

“…This was consistent with earlier estimates in the US 3 and other countries. 26 The reductions in overall estimated smoking prevalence were similar to those reported in Levy et al 3 : 10% (range, 4%-19%). However, this study's model estimated fewer smoking-attributable deaths averted during a longer period owing to the model's projections of lower smoking prevalence in the baseline scenario compared with the projections of Levy et al 3 Recent studies have found that smoking rates among US youths and young adults have decreased at especially fast rates 4,5 ; thus, the outcomes of future policy changes will be attenuated by these underlying trends at baseline.…”

Differential price responses for tobacco consumption: implications for tax incidence

“…In Argentina, there are 9 million smokers (over a total population of 45 million inhabitants) and tobacco consumption causes 45 000 deaths per year. 34 Since 2011, tobacco prevalence has diminished. According to the latest National Survey of Risk Factors, in 2018 the prevalence of cigarette consumption in the adult population was 22.2%, 7.5 percentage points below the prevalence registered in 2005.…”

Standardised packs and larger health warnings: visual attention and perceptions among Colombian smokers and non‐smokers

“…To our knowledge, this is the first experiment in Colombia testing the effects of standardised packaging and larger health warnings with these innovative methodologies (i.e., eye‐tracking and DCE) and our research supports and replicates previous work conducted elsewhere [ 7 , 8 , 10 , 12 , 20 , 27 ]. The implementation of these policies might contribute to reducing the burden that tobacco places on the Colombian economy and health care system [ 41 ]. Although governments may require, or at least welcome, ‘local’ evidence on the effects of tobacco control policies, such as larger health warnings and standardised packaging (as per the Colombian Ministry of Health) [ 1 ], our research demonstrates that these policies are likely to have similar effects cross‐culturally.…”