Hartwick's rule and maximin paths when the exhaustible resource has an amenity value

Abstract

International audienceThis paper studies the maximin paths of the canonical Dasgupta-Heal-Solow model when the stock of natural capital is a direct argument of well-being, besides consumption. Hartwick's rule then appears as an efficient tool to characterize solutions in a variety of settings. We start with the case without technical progress. We obtain an explicit solution of the maximin problem in the case where production and utility are Cobb-Douglas. When the utility function is CES with a low elasticity of substitution between consumption and natural capital, we show that it is optimal to preserve forever a critical level of natural capital, determined endogeneously. We then study how technical progress affects the optimal maximin paths, in the Cobb-Douglas utility case. On the long run path of the economy capital, production and consumption grow at a common constant rate, while the resource stock decreases at a constant rate and is therefore completely depleted in the very long run. A higher amenity value of the resource stock leads to faster economic growth, but to a lower long run rate of depletion. We then develop a complete analysis of the dynamics of the maximin problem when the sole source of well-being is consumption, and provide a numerical resolution of the model with resource amenity. The economy consumes, produces and invests less in the short run if the resource has an amenity value than if it does not, whereas it is the contrary in the medium and long runs. However, and without surprise, the resource stock remains for ever higher with resource amenity than without

A characterization of sustainability with indicators

“…Our approach results in the definition of optimal level of such constraints. We should note here that, if utility depends on actual consumption and resource stock, following the recommendations of the present criterion implies a decreasing utility (with constant consumption and decreasing resource stock), while the usual maximin path makes it possible to sustain utility (with an increasing consumption as the resource stock decreases) [14].…”

“…17 Such a path have been characterized for Cobb-Douglas preferences [14]. From a qualitative point of view, in the DHS model, both the paths have an increasing consumption with exhaustion of the resource stock.…”

The rise and fall of the Irish orange roughy fishery: An economic analysis

“…We know from the literature of optimal harvest decisions in relation to old growth forests that the presence of non-market amenity values provided by a standing forest has an important impact on when or indeed whether to harvest [75,76]. d' Autume and Schubert [77] have shown that the resource stock of an exhaustible resource remains for ever higher when it has amenity value and Conrad [75] and Reed [78] demonstrated that if the value of non-market amenities is high enough it may never be optimal to cut an old growth forest for its timber.…”

A Closed-Form Solution to Stollery’s Problem with Damage in Utility

“…For example, Baranzini and Bourguignon (1995), considered a general model where economic growth can cause a level of hazard leading to extinction, regardless of the economic "opportunities". 3 A problem technically similar to the one considered in this paper arises in the cases in which utility is positively affected by the remaining resource stock, e.g., when the stock has an amenity value (Krautkraemer 1985;D'Autume and Schubert 2008).…”