Harnessing the Combined Power of Theoretical and Experimental Data through Multiscale Informatics

Abstract

Monumental, recent and rapidly continuing, improvements in the capabilities of ab initio theoretical kinetics calculations provides reason to believe that progress in the field of chemical kinetics can be accelerated through a corresponding evolution of the role of theory in kinetic modeling and its relationship with experiment. The present article reviews and provides additional demonstrations of the unique advantages that arise when theoretical and experimental data across multiple scales are considered on equal footing, including the relevant uncertainties of both, within a single mathematical framework. Namely, the multiscale informatics framework simultaneously integrates information from a wide variety of sources and scales: ab initio electronic structure calculations of molecular properties, rate constant determinations for individual reactions, and measured global observables of multireaction systems. The resulting model representation consists of a set of theoretical kinetics parameters (with constrained uncertainties) that are related through elementary kinetics models to rate constants (with propagated uncertainties) that in turn are related through physical models to global observables (with propagated uncertainties). An overview of the approach and typical implementation is provided along with a brief discussion of the major uncertainties (parametric and structural) in theoretical kinetics calculations, kinetic models for complex chemical mechanisms, and physical models for experiments. Higher levels of automation in all aspects, including closed‐loop autonomous mixed‐experimental‐and‐computational model improvement, are advocated for facilitating scalability of the approach to larger systems with reasonable human effort and computational cost. The unique advantages of combining theoretical and experimental data across multiple scales are illustrated through a series of examples. Previous results demonstrating the utility of simultaneous interpretation of theoretical and experimental data for assessing consistency in complex systems and for reliable, physics‐based extrapolation of limited data are briefly summarized. New results are presented to demonstrate the high predictive accuracy of multiscale informed models for both small (molecular properties) and large (global observables) scales. These new results provide examples where the optimization yields physically realistic parameter adjustments and where physical model uncertainties in experiments are larger than kinetic model uncertainties. New results are also presented to demonstrate the utility of the multiscale informatics approach for design of experiments and theoretical calculations, accounting for both theoretical and experimental existing knowledge as well as relevant parametric and structural uncertainties in interpreting potential new data. These new results provide examples where neglecting structural uncertainties in design of experiments results in failure to identify the most worthwhile experiment. Further progress in the c...

From theoretical reaction dynamics to chemical modeling of combustion

“…The role of theory in developing a detailed molecular level description of low-temperature radical oxidation is then summarized through a review of our long-term studies of ethyl and propyl radical oxidations. A semiquantitative understanding of the uncertainties in theoretical predictions can be of great value in modeling, as demonstrated by Burke in his multiscale modeling approach [ 28 ]. These studies ultimately led us to the realization that at combustion temperatures the foundational assumption of thermalization prior to reaction is not always valid, and further that its breakdown significantly affects key combustion properties.…”

Shock Tube Laser Schlieren Study of the Pyrolysis of Isopropyl Nitrate

“…The combination of parameters that minimized the sum of square error between the log of the measured rate constants and the log of the RRKM/ME predictions was chosen as the optimum set. The optimization of electronic structure and master equation properties against experimental data is inspired by the Multiscale Informatics of Burke and co-workers. − …”

Bath Gas Mixture Effects on Multichannel Reactions: Insights and Representations for Systems beyond Single-Channel Reactions

“…In the meantime, mixture rules should be considered a significant structural uncertainty in chemical kinetics simulations and uncertainty quantification, 66−69 as discussed elsewhere. 69 While the present calculations use the commonly employed exponential-down model to facilitate straightforward interpretations of the analytical solutions and to allow compatibility with the vast majority of calculated rate constants, which use the same model, improved quantification of mixture effects in future studies could be attained by using energy and angular momentum transfer functions determined via trajectory calculations and/or experimental measurements within a twodimensional master equation. Naturally, as with rate constant calculations for even single-component bath gases for many pressure-dependent reactions, such mixture studies await such data to become available for a wider variety of bath gases and reactant complexes.…”