Hadza Women's Time Allocation, Offspring Provisioning, and the Evolution of Long Postmenopausal Life Spans

Abstract

Extended provisioning of offspring and long postmenopausal life spans are characteristic of all modem humans but no other pri mates. These traits may have evolved in tandem. Analysis of rela tionships between women's time allocation and children's nutri tional welfare among the Hadza of northern Tanzania yields results consistent with this proposition. Implications for current thought about the evolution of hominid food sharing, life his tory, and social organization are discussed. k r i s t e n h a w k e s is Professor of Anthropology at the University of Utah (Salt Lake City, Utah 84112, U.S.A.). She earned a B.S. from Iowa State University (1968) and a Master's (1970) and Ph.D. (1976) from the University of Washington and has done ex tended fieldwork with the Binumarien of the eastern highlands of Papua New Guinea, the Ache of eastern Paraguay, and the Hadza of northern Tanzania. Her recent publications include "Why Hunter-Gatherers Work: An Ancient Version of the Prob lem of Public Goods" (c u r r e n t a n t h r o p o l o g y 34:341-61), "For aging Differences between Men and Women: Behavioral Ecology of the Sexual Division of Labor," in Power, Sex, and Tradition, edited by S. Shennan and J. Steele (London: Routledge, 1996), and (with J. F. O'Connell and L. Rogers) "The Behavioral Ecology of Modern Hunter-Gatherers and Human Evolution" [Trends in Ecology and Evolution 12:29-32). j a m e s f. o ' c o n n e l l is Professor of Anthropology at the Univer sity of Utah. Bom in 1943, he was educated at the University of 1. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation, the Swan Fund, B. Bancroft, the University of Utah, and the Uni versity of California at Los Angeles. We thank Utafiti (Tanzanian National Research Council) for permission to pursue fieldwork, C. Kamazora for guidance, D. Bygott and J. Hanby for continued vital assistance, and the Hadza themselves for tolerance, advice, and support. K. Heath, J. Coltrain, K. Lupo, L. Travis, and B. Clark con tributed many hours to coding field notes; T. Schurtz provided pa tient data management; D. Huth gave us statistical advice. U. Hanly prepared the figure and provided important editorial assis tance. R. Bliege Bird, K. Hill, E. Cashdan, and A. Rogers offered in structive criticism of an earlier draft. California, Berkeley (Ph.D., 1971). He has been a research fellow in prehistory at the Research School of Pacific Studies, Austra lian National University. His research interests are prehistoric and modem hunter-gatherers and evolutionary ecology, and his publications include "Ethnoarchaeology Needs a General Theory of Behavior" (Journal of Archaeological Research 3:205-55) and (with F. J. Allen) the edited volume Transitions: Pleistocene to Holocene in Australia and Papua New Guinea (Antiquity 269). N i c h o l a s g. b l u r t o n j o n e s is Professor in the Departments of Anthropology, Education, and Psychiatry at the University of California, Los Angeles. He received his D.Phil. in zoology from Oxford University in 1964, and his research interest...

Why do good hunters have higher reproductive success?

“…Among the Hadza, the fact that the wives and children of better hunters display greater seasonal weight gains (Hawkes 1993b) may be associated with variation in women's foraging returns rather than those of their husbands (Hawkes et al 1997). However, Marlowe (2003) has recently shown that Hadza women with very young children (<3 years old), and especially those with infants (<1 year old), have reduced foraging productivity, both in average daily harvest and in hourly return rates while foraging.…”

The effects of residential locality on parental and alloparental investment among the Aka foragers of the central African Republic

“…However, McBurney et al (2002) notes that in Pashos' study the paternal bias in caregiving is focused toward grandsons, which may simply be an extension of the patriarchal norms, and that the patriarchal system is likely overriding the matrilateral bias. Evidence also shows that maternal grandmothers invest more in their daughters' offspring than in their sons' offspring (Blurton Jones et al 2005;Hawkes et al 1997). Hawkes et al (2000) suggest that while grandmaternal assistance directed toward a son's offspring could aid their own fitness, assistance directed toward daughters' offspring yields clearer benefits owing to genetic certainty.…”

“…The importance of grandmaternal investment has been used to explain long postmenopausal lifespans, as well as impacts on maternal fertility and infant survivorship (Hawkes 1997). In particular, maternal grandmothers offer the most support, although patrilocal residence patterns would minimize the assistance that maternal grandmothers could offer.…”

“…This variation could help explain periods of matrilocality, such as among the Aka, whereby women can receive the support of their mothers when they most need it. Evidence shows that grandmothers direct assistance to the daughters that require the most aid (Blurton Jones et al 2005, Hawkes et al 1997.…”

“…Alloparents are individuals other than the biological parents who invest in children. They have been shown to increase maternal reproductive success (Bereczkei and Dunbar 2002;Sear et al 2003) and aid in infant survivorship (Hawkes et al 1997;Ivey 2000). Studies have shown that humans are cooperative childrearers and that successful rearing of offspring may be dependent on alloparental assistance (Hrdy 2005;Ivey 2000).…”