“…Each study lake contains a different prey community (Figure , Appendix S2): (a) Lake 373 has abundant (~13 per m 3 , Paterson, Podemski, Wesson, & Dupuis, ), cold‐water invertebrate prey Mysis diluviana, or Mysis hereafter; (b) Lake 626 has yellow perch Perca flavescens (introduced ca. 2005—Wall & Blanchfield, ), a forage fish of moderate size, with a preferred temperature (~18°C—Hasnain et al., ) that exceeds the preferred temperature for lake trout by an amount sufficient to ensure that it is typically found in epilimnetic and/or littoral habitats that are thermally hostile to lake trout in summer; (c) Lake Louisa has no alternate prey; consequently, lake trout diet is dominated by zooplankton and littoral minnows (Konkle & Sprules, ; Morbey et al., ); and (d) Lake Opeongo has abundant (~0.03 per m 3 —Moryk, ) cisco Coregonus artedi , a large pelagic, cold‐water planktivore which is a preferred prey for lake trout—Matuszek et al., ; Shuter et al., ), along with yellow perch. Prey resources in Lakes 626 and Louisa are similar in that larger vertebrate prey (perch, minnows) are found in epilimnetic/littoral environments that were thermally hostile to lake trout during the study period (Figure ).…”