We present new high-resolution H I spectral line imaging of Coma P, the brightest H I source in the system HI 1232 +20. This galaxy with extremely low surface brightness was first identified in the ALFALFA survey as an "(Almost) Dark" object: a clearly extragalactic H I source with no obvious optical counterpart in existing optical survey data (although faint ultraviolet emission was detected in archival GALEX imaging). Using a combination of data from the Westerbork Synthesis Radio Telescope and the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array, we investigate the H I morphology and kinematics at a variety of physical scales. The H I morphology is irregular, reaching only moderate maxima in mass surface density (peak M 10 H I s~ pc −2 ). Gas of lower surface brightness extends to large radial distances, with the H I diameter measured at 4.0±0.2 kpc inside the M 1 pc −2 level. We quantify the relationships between mass surface density of H I gas and star formation on timescales of ∼100-200 Myr as traced by GALEX far-ultraviolet emission. While Coma P has regions of dense H I gas reaching the N 10 I I scaling relation. It is either too large for its H I mass, has too low an H I mass for its H I size, or the two H I components artificially extend its H I size. Coma P lies within the empirical scatter at the faint end of the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation, although the complexity of the H I dynamics complicates the interpretation. Along with its large ratio of H I to stellar mass, the collective H I characteristics of Coma P make it unusual among known galaxies in the nearby universe.