Guarding the Sons of Empire: Military–State–Society Relations in Water, Sanitation and Health Programs of mid-19th-Century India

Abstract

Drinking water supply and sanitation have had a strong association with military institutions in South Asia from the colonial period to the present. This paper shows how military-state-society relationships created spaces of differential water access and sanitation burdens in mid-19th-century cantonments in ways that involved complex gender relations. In comparison with previous research, we argue that privileged military enclaves were segregated but never fully separated from larger urban water and sanitation systems. We use historical geographic methods to review the evolving role of military sanitation regulations in cantonments from late-18th-century policies of the East India Company (EIC) through mid-19th-century rule by the British Crown, during which time military cantonments, regulations, and formal monitoring reports were established. Close reading of the British Army Medical Department’s Statistical, Sanitary, and Medical Reports (Sanitary Reports) in the 1860s then shows how military-state-society relations diverged from civilian public health programs in ways that persist to some extent to the present day. Health advisors, some of them women, pursued an ideology and tactics to “guard the sons of empire”, from what they perceived to be a disease-filled landscape of “lurking evils”, “choleric attacks”, and “native offensives”. We conclude with a discussion of both continuities and change in the relationships between military and civilian public health reforms beyond the barracks.

Application of the Kilimanjaro Concept in Reversing Seawater Intrusion and Securing Water Supply in Zanzibar, Tanzania

“…During this German rule and the time under British rule, the colonial administration designed some water supply systems, but not primarily for Tanzanians. The situation was similar to the one described in India by [77]. This is the origin of the African tragedy, not only in water supply.…”

Critical Water Geographies: From Histories to Affect

“…From the relevance of the historic intellectual trope of quantitative methods to actual historical texts on British water, sanitation and health practices in 18th and 19th century India, Halvorson and Wescoat (2020) [4] remind us of how colonial imaginaries cast a long shadow over contemporary urban water and sanitation geographies in South Asia. Reading the British Army Medical Department's Statistical, Sanitary and Medical Reports (Sanitary Reports) from the 1860s, they provide a rich account of how military-state-society relations diverged from civilian public health programs.…”

Universal Access to Safe Drinking Water: Escaping the Traps of Non-Frugal Technologies

“…The international community has achieved the Millennium Development Goal 7C of halving the number of people without access to "improved" water supply by 2015 [1,2]. However, this success still leaves some 1.8 billion world citizens without safe drinking water, and 144 million continue to drink untreated surface water drawn from rivers or lakes [3,4]. It is hoped now, that through a synthesis of available knowledge and concerted research efforts, universal access to safe drinking water will be achieved by 2030 [1,5,6].…”

“…The battle for a universal safe drinking water supply had started around 1950, when the world was divided into the following two groups: (i) the developed world with universal access to safe drinking water (and sanitation), and (ii) the developing world without proper access to safe drinking water, and a population prone to waterborne diseases [4,7]. It is rather surprising, that apart from China and a few countries who have significantly progressed since then, the situation remains unchanged 70 years later.…”