Growing concerns and controversies to Taiwan's National Health Insurance—what are the lessons from mainland China, South Korea and Singapore?

Abstract

It has been over 20 years since Taiwan's implementation of its National Health Insurance (NHI) program. Under this program, the health insurance coverage rate has reached approximately 99% of the population. Despite guaranteeing the residents of Taiwan equal access regardless of socioeconomic status and background, critical problems and controversies persist, and they continue to challenge the NHI. We analyze the primary issues facing the NHI program with emphasis on financial and consumer behavioral aspects. Furthermore, we apply models from mainland China, South Korea and Singapore to discuss what Taiwan could learn from the systems employed by these countries to modify the NHI. Targeting the needs of the NHI, we have three policy recommendations: separating the NHI scheme into different target populations, strengthening the NHI referral system and regulating the access of overseas citizens to health services while in Taiwan. After two decades in existence, problems persist and there is a continuing need to improve Taiwan's NHI. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Urban-Rural Disparities in The Utilization of Primary Health Care Center Among Elderly in East Java, Indonesia

“…The study on the effect of insurance usage have often been conducted. The results of the study showed a positive correlation (El-Sayed, Vail and Kruk, 2018;Johar et al, 2018;Lee et al, 2018). Note: (a) The reference category was "no utilization"; (b) Floating point overflow occurred while computing this statistic.…”

Is preventive care utilization associated with lower outpatient and inpatient health‐care expenses among Chinese older adults? A longitudinal analysis

“…For example, Taiwan's universal health‐care system has been highly regarded; however, because its health‐care system does not provide a robust gatekeeper system, people could consistently seek unnecessary health care when they are not seriously ill . Hence, more than 30 000 insured residents in Taiwan made over 100 health‐care services per year . As the Chinese health‐care system does not have an effective gatekeeper system, a condition similar to Taiwan's could occur in China because the results of this study indicated a positive association between preventive care utilization and outpatient treatment expenses.…”

“…In fact, such behavior is evident in other Asian regions. For example, Taiwan's universal health‐care system has been highly regarded; however, because its health‐care system does not provide a robust gatekeeper system, people could consistently seek unnecessary health care when they are not seriously ill . Hence, more than 30 000 insured residents in Taiwan made over 100 health‐care services per year .…”

Urban-Rural Disparities of Facility-Based Childbirth in Indonesia

“…Various studies in several countries on the impact of ownership of health insurance have found findings that have increased the use of health services that is far better (Lee et al, 2018) (Tilahun et al, 2018) (Miraldo, Propper and Williams, 2018) (Müllerschön et al, 2019). The same conditions apply to Indonesia (Mubasyiroh, Nurhotimah and Laksono, 2016) (Laksono, Wulandari and Soedirham, 2019b).…”